bullet selection for mountain goat

[Eochsenkehl]

this will n[be my first goat hunt Im between the 7prc and the 300 win , what bullets are you guys using ?

 

[Back Country Hunter 2]

I'm going this year in Colorado. I've never shot a mountain goat, but planning on using my 6.5 PRC. After seeing it absolutely destroy a moose 2 seasons ago I've got confidence in that rifle for anything in Colorado. Shoot whatever you are more accurate with.

 

[Eochsenkehl]

** This will be my first mountain goat hunt. I'm between the 7 prc and the 300 win, what bullets are you guys using?

 

[Marbles]

I will be using a short barrel 243 with 108 gr ELDMs.

 

[Firestone]

I'm also hunting my first goat. Plan on using a 6.5prc, 156eol

 

[Eochsenkehl]

I will be using a short barrel 243 with 108 gr ELDMs.

have you used this for goats before? I was leaning toward the large cartridges because all I hear about goats is how tough they and their ability to soak up lead

 

[Fetty Wapiti]

I have seen more goats die by 6.5 creed than I care to admit. I know of seven that died out to 500 yards with 124 hammer hunters. Anything will do.

 

[Marbles]

have you used this for goats before? I was leaning toward the large cartridges because all I hear about goats is how tough they and their ability to soak up lead

I have not, but the wound channel diameter should match that of a larger caliber with "tougher" bullets. Goats are not particularly large, so penetration depth is not a large concern, they are not cape buffalo.

I would take a heavy for caliber fragmenting bullet for whatever cartridge you select; ELDM/X, Berger, TMK, etc; 220ish gr for 30 cal, 160ish for 7mm, Etc. Taking a larger caliber, than selecting a bullet that creates a smaller wound channel is not logical. Wound channels in vital organs, not headstamps, kill.

Free advice from someone on the Internet who has lost their marbles is probably worth about what you pay for it.

 

[ljalberta]

have you used this for goats before? I was leaning toward the large cartridges because all I hear about goats is how tough they and their ability to soak up lead

I’d suspect the ability for goats to soak lead is more due to the shot placement of the shooters, and less to do with a goat being a particularly tough creature. Often shots are at steeper angles, higher altitudes, and can be in windier conditions. Most people hunting goats are already poor shots on the flats, let alone adding in these additional elements.

 

[Eochsenkehl]

I have seen more goats die by 6.5 creed than I care to admit. I know of seven that died out to 500 yards with 124 hammer hunters. Anything will do.

thanks

 

[Eochsenkehl]

I have not, but the wound channel diameter should match that of a larger caliber with "tougher" bullets. Goats are not particularly large, so penetration depth is not a large concern, they are not cape buffalo.

I would take a heavy for caliber fragmenting bullet for whatever cartridge you select; ELDM/X, Berger, TMK, etc; 220ish gr for 30 cal, 160ish for 7mm, Etc. Taking a larger caliber, than selecting a bullet that creates a smaller wound channel is not logical. Wound channels in vital organs, not headstamps, kill.

Free advice from someone on the Internet who has lost their marbles is probably worth about what you pay for

I have not, but the wound channel diameter should match that of a larger caliber with "tougher" bullets. Goats are not particularly large, so penetration depth is not a large concern, they are not cape buffalo.

I would take a heavy for caliber fragmenting bullet for whatever cartridge you select; ELDM/X, Berger, TMK, etc; 220ish gr for 30 cal, 160ish for 7mm, Etc. Taking a larger caliber, than selecting a bullet that creates a smaller wound channel is not logical. Wound channels in vital organs, not headstamps, kill.

Free advice from someone on the Internet who has lost their marbles is probably worth about what you pay for it.

appreciate the insight

 

[Wyo_hntr]

7prc/eldm. I have zero experience with mountain goats but they are not mythical creatures.

 

[Hondo0925]

Listen to the podcast by Exo Mountain gear with Form.
@Mark at EXO

 

[JO.]

Listen to the podcast by Exo Mountain gear with Form.
@Mark at EXO

Do you know the date or title of the episode? Thanks!

 

[JO.]

My wife has a CO tag this year and will be using - 6.5prc and 156 bergers.

 

[IDVortex]

Do you know the date or title of the episode? Thanks!

It was I think about a month ago?

 

[Decker9]

Shot selection is more important than bullet selection imo. Ime every goat is different. Be sure they’re in a retrievable spot, aim for lungs and let fly.

But for myself, I’ll choose a tougher bullet every time.

 

[Hondo0925]

469 | Why Smaller Calibers May Be Better For Big Game Hunting (Part 1) — The Experience Project

This podcast will challenge decades of "common knowledge" about what type of rifle and bullet should be used for big game hunting. In fact, if you can't have an

podcasts.apple.com

 

[hamkyl16]

300 WM 200gr ELDX or Terminal Accent on goats for me. But I’m a one rifle guy for Alaska.

 

[StopMakingSense]

The goat in my picture was shot with a 145 LRX that made a broadhead sized hole in the lungs) and spined due to a 42deg shot angle, I was pretty damn lucky. I haven't used copper for a while now. I was originally on the 'save the meat' train which was BS, I'd rather see 'em drop right away.

We've shot a couple with 160 Accubonds with better results.

ELDM/X are still the deadliest we've used.

They're tough animals but they don't do much walking when the lungs are blown up with a fragmenting bullet.