Wife & I have used the SO 8 person Tipi on 3 Alaskan hunts. It’s worked well and has stood up to some vicious winds. For us, the woodstove is a must as we like to dry out wet stuff (including ourselves). We’ve had rain most of our days hunting moose.
The footprint is pretty big and I don’t love the wasted space around the edges, but the thing has been good overall. You’ll need a half liner to reduce condensation. Two of them might even be better. We bought the combo with the XL stove. The firebox is still pretty small and if requires frequent feeding, especially with the wood available up there.
I’m intrigued by the SO Redcliff and might look into it before next year’s hunt. It’s just hard to go away from our current setup as we know it works.,