Best Puffy?

Olympics777

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jun 16, 2014
Messages
182
Location
Moscow ID
Cannot not recommend this coat any stronger. I tried this coat and it’s literally made for dwarves. It’s the worst cut/shape of any puffy or all time. Terrible hood design as well.

It’s a warm coat with good materials overall. But unwearable in the back country unless you’re child size.
I was wondering about this, the Feathered friends puffys look nice but I’ve seen multiple people say they run short. That’s disappointing, I’ll have to look at Rab or montbell instead. I don’t want to pay 400 bucks for something that doesn’t cover my torso.
 

atmat

WKR
Joined
Jun 10, 2022
Messages
3,192
Location
Colorado
i can second the ghost whisperer. amazing warmth/weight ratio and i find it warmer than my patagonia down sweater which i believe has more down.

are you comparing to the kuiu pro down? that would be impressive and worth knowing given its 5oz of 850 FP down.
The MH Ghost Whisperer 2 jacket and pants are great. The jacket packs into its own pocket. The pants come with a tiny stuff sack. Since they’re not treated I tend to store in a ziplock in my bag. Plus it gives me a spare ziplock should I need it.
 

sr80

WKR
Joined
Feb 19, 2014
Messages
1,400
Location
British Columbia
I was just at the BC hunting expo and salute to conservation in Penticton BC (BC sheep show), and sitka had a booth there, and they had a not released new sitka puffy on the rack. It is supposed to be coming out this summer. Called the Kelvin Hyper Down jacket, made to replace the kelvin down WS jacket. The rep didnt seem to have a ton of info on it, hate when that happens. But it was NICE, great fit, a tad bit longer in the torso than the WS kelvin (i found the sitka kelvin down to be very wide and short), the outer material didnt seem as burly and durable. But its a nice like jacket with a ton of down fill, i did find a primaloft tag inside so im guessing it has synthetic in the shoulders and maybe arms? Or it could by something mixed with the down, but it was nice and light felt good. Pretty excited for this one.
 

Appalaskan

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
173
Recently acquired a feathered friends down jacket in the classifieds. Here is a photo of the Grumman, Montbell and Feathered Friends. I also have the Kuiu Super Down Pro. Of the 4 Feathered Friends is stacked with down but is shorter than the Montbell so they would be very close in total warmth. The Grumman is warm but simply less down than the other 3. If you want a burner down coat I would look to the Feathered Friends or Montbell. The most packable would be the Grumman or Kuiu. None should be used brush busting not their design.
There’s
Recently acquired a feathered friends down jacket in the classifieds. Here is a photo of the Grumman, Montbell and Feathered Friends. I also have the Kuiu Super Down Pro. Of the 4 Feathered Friends is stacked with down but is shorter than the Montbell so they would be very close in total warmth. The Grumman is warm but simply less down than the other 3. If you want a burner down coat I would look to the Feathered Friends or Montbell. The most packable would be the Grumman or Kuiu. None should be used brush busting not their design.
There’s ol’ Betsy.
 
Joined
Dec 14, 2020
Messages
92
Location
Wisconsin

Rokslide turned me on to this and I think it’s awesome…
Have this jacket. I love it and wear it a ton. Definitely size up
 

Rommy

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jan 31, 2018
Messages
200
Location
phoenix arizona
Im a huge fan of my Patagonia puffy, very lightweight and packable and warm for its weight. I wear it under a thin softshell if needed to protect it from brush and that combination is very flexible to layer with. Not a hunting brand but the quality is there and I havent been losing any down.

Which piece?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Koda_

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Dec 24, 2023
Messages
297
Location
PNW
Which piece?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sorry I get my brands confused. My UL rainjacket is a Patagonia Torrentshell.
My UL puffy is a Marmot... its old and they dont make this one anymore, theres no name label on it except marmot. The modern equivalent is their mens Highlander Jacket, 700fill down, weighs just under a lb., pretty much exactly what I have. Id buy another one if needed without concern. Or alternatively a Patagonia puffy of the same weight.
 
Joined
Aug 4, 2019
Messages
1,350
Location
North Carolina
REI makes a great 850 fill puffy that you can pick up for ~$100 around Black Friday. I've had mine for years & it's great. Have bought 5 more for family/ friends.
 

moab

FNG
Joined
Apr 29, 2024
Messages
31
Outdoor gear lab tests the best outdoor gear every year.
Mountaineering companies make the best cold weather gear.
Outdoor Gearlab is a gold mine of review information. They test everything you can imagine. By sending it out with world class hikers, backpackers and trekkers. For weeks or longer at a time. Often for complete seasons. Great in depth reviews of the top products in each category. So they will not just review. But review and compare to the top competition to each other. They also call out best budget picks.

I have learned a lot from that site.
 

realunlucky

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Jan 20, 2013
Messages
13,116
Location
Eastern Utah
Outdoor Gearlab is a gold mine of review information. They test everything you can imagine. By sending it out with world class hikers, backpackers and trekkers. For weeks or longer at a time. Often for complete seasons. Great in depth reviews of the top products in each category. So they will not just review. But review and compare to the top competition to each other. They also call out best budget picks.

I have learned a lot from that site.
Curious how a world class hiker, backpacker and trekker is qualified from a regular hiker, backpacker and trekker?

Sent from my SM-S926U using Tapatalk
 
Joined
Jan 30, 2022
Messages
1,126
Outdoor Gearlab is a gold mine of review information. They test everything you can imagine. By sending it out with world class hikers, backpackers and trekkers. For weeks or longer at a time. Often for complete seasons. Great in depth reviews of the top products in each category. So they will not just review. But review and compare to the top competition to each other. They also call out best budget picks.

I have learned a lot from that site.
I really like their reviews, I just wish they'd also compare to hunting brands so we can see how they stack up. Since they don't go head to head we have to make our own inferences and sometimes spec sheets don't tell the whole story
 

croben

WKR
Joined
Aug 21, 2022
Messages
328
I really like their reviews, I just wish they'd also compare to hunting brands so we can see how they stack up. Since they don't go head to head we have to make our own inferences and sometimes spec sheets don't tell the whole story
I’ve thought the same thing many times. I wish they would test and review hunting brands products.
 
Joined
Jan 30, 2022
Messages
1,126
I’ve thought the same thing many times. I wish they would test and review hunting brands products.
Just at least to give us a fair comparison. I don't deny the quality of some outdoor hiking brand gear and I use it interchangeably. However the quality and function of technical hunting brands has skyrocketed and it would be great to have a direct compare
 

krob2299

FNG
Joined
Sep 11, 2022
Messages
5
Looking at going a different direction with my puffy jacket and curious what everybody else is running. I currently have the Kuiu Super Down Ultra, and I like it. The weight is great and it’s pretty warm in most situations, but every single time I wear it it seems like I lose a handful of down feathers, and kys definitely not as warm as it used to be with 3 years of feather loss at this point. Any recommendations? Grumman, kuiu, Kifaru?
Why not jump to the pro? Or black ovis if you wanna save some cash, I've got the BO one and it's been phenomenal for what it costs
 
Joined
Dec 5, 2019
Messages
1,146
I’m going to try out the Feathered friends EOS. Specs are really good and they’re on sale right now. Made in the USA also
 
Top