Yeah for some odd reason I cant do dill pickles, and it's weird, I like bread and butter pickles, sweet pickles, sweet relish etc. just fine lol. But something with dill pickles i cant do, i guess its the dill. I guess a fella could do sweet relish as a substituteThe dill relish and the worcestershire are what make it so good! But everybody's tastes are different. It'll probably still be good without it. Might be able to chop up some pickled jalapeño as a substitute if you like that better. In fact, I think I'm going to try that next time lol