Lot of thoughts on this thread. Me, I have used shoulder shot effectively with an 06 when waiting for WT to come off the ridge right before quitting time. I wouldn't do it in mid day vs a good lung shot. Really liked seeing the deer go down quick without a whole lot of tracking. of course Dad cussed a lot at me every time when we were cutting them up. He still makes me bone out necks and ribs for grind (at 86!)
Probably would have rethought strategy if I was shooting lower than a .270.
only time I regretted the strategy was when I had a buck shot through shoulders plow into not just one but two trees and break off both antlers 30 years ago. Had enough left to make it legal. A bit disappointing at when your 21 to shoot a six and end up with a spike on one side. Still tasted good.
High shoulder shots for me. I really like shooting a highly volatile round such as Berger or Nosler BT as they dump more energy into the body cavity. The high shoulder often results in a severed spine plus several the dorsal aorta which leads to a very fast death right on the spot. You know you hit them in the sweet spot when their rear end drops out from underneath. But do not confuse this shot with a spine shot.
Watched whitetail television for the first time in forever a few weeks back. A couple shows in a row it seemed they were all going for this shot and a dramatic flop but 3 of 4 missed the mark. Left a bad taste in my mouth. I get it for certain circumstances but in these circumstances they had no reason to do it on deer standing in the middle of a 10 acre food plot. Couldn't help but thinking about how piss poor it was to go for this shot when there's no reason for it only to miss the mark inside 100 yards with a solid rest. Embarrassing.
Im also a proponent of high shoulder shots for WT bucks to anchor them. i will neck shoot a doe to anchor and since there isnt much neck meat on a doe you still get the shoulders. Although blood trailing is a necessary woodsman skill to hone, IMO it creates unnecessary room for opportunities to not recover a deer, no matter how dead. Especially if hunting mountainous terrain where a heart shot death sprint could result in a long arduous packout in steep laurel ridden hell-hole drainages.
Does your shot placement change with bears? I recently shot my first black bear high shoulder with 165gr barns tsx federal premium. Research would indicate that bears die quickly with well placed vital area shots, but are notoriously difficult to blood trail due to fat and hair. They can also curl up into hard to find balls of fur and tuck into inconspicuous holes, making it even harder to recover a dead animal. This shot effectively immobilized the 250lb sow by shattering both shoulders, and the bullets performed well by my estimation. However it did not flip the "off switch" and i had to humblingly dispatch, unpleasantly hearing the death moan from about 5ft.
Do bears have the same off switch? Is there a better shot placement location to "anchor" and mitigate risk of non-recovery?