7 Broke Backcountry Reloading Vid

Joined
Oct 15, 2022
Messages
68
Anyone else catch the video Federal put out showing that their "alloy" case is reloadable? I think its all kinda BS and the video is missing many important details, all of which are the reasons people say its not reloadable. They also talk about the "premium" ammo cases are coated inside and out making them reloadable, but the cheaper stuff thats dull is only coated inside thus not recommended to be reloaded.

I dont know if they are thinking its a case stuck in die issue or what but they didnt show a single measurement of the case to show any sort of shoulder bump. I saw its taking 12 passes of a resizing die to get the case sized. This dude in a dorky lab coat does it in a single pass... no trimming or anything. just a video of the guy making a round with a sharpie mark on it and shooting it again.

Anyway, curious what the thoughts are of anyone who's seen it.
 

TaperPin

WKR
Joined
Jul 12, 2023
Messages
3,963
Demo rifles have been out for two years. There must be some hang ups if there’s still no reloading data or more reloading information other than the dude making the RCBS commercial. Or was it a Federal commercial? It sure felt like a RCBS commercial except there are no actual dies on the shelves.

I predict the cartridge will be a flop because it won’t be easily reloadable and that will sour dedicated shooters on the idea - in three years it will be an oddball has been.
 

Rotnguns

WKR
Joined
Apr 11, 2020
Messages
483
Location
Southwest Idaho
You mean this one?
He makes it look pretty easy. Modulus of elasticity for brass is about half what it is for high-strength steel; I'd expect it to be harder to reform, and yet he full-length resized in the video without much undo effort. Rather surprising, since the case has to deform plastically when resized. But, steel takes a permanent set under less strain than brass. He also noted that he used prototype dies that aren't available yet. Will be very interesting to see these dies when they come out!
 

Rotnguns

WKR
Joined
Apr 11, 2020
Messages
483
Location
Southwest Idaho
Demo rifles have been out for two years. There must be some hang ups if there’s still no reloading data or more reloading information other than the dude making the RCBS commercial. Or was it a Federal commercial? It sure felt like a RCBS commercial except there are no actual dies on the shelves.

I predict the cartridge will be a flop because it won’t be easily reloadable and that will sour dedicated shooters on the idea - in three years it will be an oddball has been.
Good points - he used an RCBS press and primer seater in the video, but mentioned prototype dies that aren't out yet. Since steel is far more brittle than brass, I'd guess that case life will be short.
 

TaperPin

WKR
Joined
Jul 12, 2023
Messages
3,963
Good points - he used an RCBS press and primer seater in the video, but mentioned prototype dies that aren't out yet. Since steel is far more brittle than brass, I'd guess that case life will be short.
Hopefully they figure it out - it would be nice to have an improvement in the basic brass case.
 

Baddog

WKR
Joined
Feb 26, 2020
Messages
424
I don’t think most people care about reloading. Certainly people on here do but I always figured most hunters are using factory ammo. What percentage of hunters are reloaders?
 
OP
NVUplandHunter
Joined
Oct 15, 2022
Messages
68
I don’t think most people care about reloading. Certainly people on here do but I always figured most hunters are using factory ammo. What percentage of hunters are reloaders?
i agree. i think this round is for the guy who has no interest in reloading.

the point im making about it is that they are saying it can be reloaded and did a video but didnt address the concerns people have such as resizing. sure he did a resize but just because he ran the die doesnt mean it worked. as i said in the post i believe rcbs said 12 passes for it to resize. the amount of effort they put in to "disprove" the reloading concerns was minimal.
 
OP
NVUplandHunter
Joined
Oct 15, 2022
Messages
68
What did Federal do to you to generate so much hate and discontent?
I think the mass release to social influencers was one thing to start. It’s kind of annoying at this point how much shilling there is going on.

Next they came out as if they had some new revolutionary thing when steel alloy cases have been around for a long time.

Then they started saying it can do things it currently can’t and then make some video about reloading the round and then say “yeah see we told you could… but also nothing is available and we are still prototyping dies and there’s no load data yet…”
 
Joined
May 22, 2023
Messages
386
I don’t think most people care about reloading. Certainly people on here do but I always figured most hunters are using factory ammo. What percentage of hunters are reloaders?
The real question is what percentage of hunter are working off the same box of ammo they bought in the 2000s. I beat that number is higher then reloaders.

I know a few myself. I’m the only person I know that reloads anything. At least family and friends.
 

wind gypsy

"DADDY"
Joined
Dec 30, 2014
Messages
10,262
I think the mass release to social influencers was one thing to start. It’s kind of annoying at this point how much shilling there is going on.
Odd to be perturbed by a company trying to get their product some marketing/media exposure. What should they have done? Played it cool and made sure nobody heard about it so only the industry hipsters were up with it?
Next they came out as if they had some new revolutionary thing when steel alloy cases have been around for a long time.
There were electric cars 100 years ago but they weren't teslas or rivians. If you could point me to some other examples of modern ammunition using steel cases to load at 80k PSI and get performance on par with cartridges that burn much more powder and have notably more recoil, i'll agree. 6.8 Fury is about it far as I know and it's a little different with the hybrid case. Frankly that hybrid case seems a little more enticing but still. It's more different than almost all other cartridge intros I can recall.
Then they started saying it can do things it currently can’t and then make some video about reloading the round and then say “yeah see we told you could… but also nothing is available and we are still prototyping dies and there’s no load data yet…”
This seems like a "To Be Determined" item. You may be right but i've seen nothing conclusive.
 
OP
NVUplandHunter
Joined
Oct 15, 2022
Messages
68
Odd to be perturbed by a company trying to get their product some marketing/media exposure. What should they have done? Played it cool and made sure nobody heard about it so only the industry hipsters were up with it?

There were electric cars 100 years ago but they weren't teslas or rivians. If you could point me to some other examples of modern ammunition using steel cases to load at 80k PSI and get performance on par with cartridges that burn much more powder and have notably more recoil, i'll agree. 6.8 Fury is about it far as I know and it's a little different with the hybrid case. Frankly that hybrid case seems a little more enticing but still. It's more different than almost all other cartridge intros I can recall.

This seems like a "To Be Determined" item. You may be right but i've seen nothing conclusive.
my gripe with the influencers is just that, they are influencers. people paid to push a product and the massive hype. the day it came out it was like my whole youtube and instagram was filled with nothing but 7BC. not because its great or anything but because Federal paid a bunch of people to push their new round. This isnt a specific annoyance to Federal either, the whole idea of social media influencers just annoys me in general. It becomes a trend overnight for no other reasons other than the fact some dude you like to watch says its good... while being paid to say its good.

Remington did a patent in the 70's on steel cases and the russians have been doing it for a long time too. There plenty of 5.56 and pistol ammo in steel cases as well. Its not a new concept at all. and sure it can handle higher case pressures.. big deal. you can push brass to that too if you only want one shot out of it. making it no different than this steel case.

My issue is not so much with the round itself. maybe i didnt make it super clear.. i guess what im getting at is this is just a huge hype game thats caught Federal a lot of heat. In trying to combat that heat they are getting they are putting out videos that dont actually address the issues. Rather than coming out and being honest about it or just saying its not a round that has been designed to reload. But dont put out some shit to try and gaslight people and not actually address the concerns, such as resizing. how hard would it be to throw a comparator gauge on the case to show a shoulder bump?
 

wind gypsy

"DADDY"
Joined
Dec 30, 2014
Messages
10,262
Remington did a patent in the 70's on steel cases and the russians have been doing it for a long time too. There plenty of 5.56 and pistol ammo in steel cases as well. Its not a new concept at all. and sure it can handle higher case pressures.. big deal. you can push brass to that too if you only want one shot out of it. making it no different than this steel case.

I've you're ok with having a higher likelihood of piercing primers and having to beat a bolt open, maybe. Not the same.
 
Joined
Feb 26, 2024
Messages
42
Location
KY
What did Federal do to you to generate so much hate and discontent?
Once the largest US small arms ammunition manufacturer, Federal Premium sold out to the Czechoslovak Group for only $25/share plus a share per share of $GEAR to $VSTO shareholders.

With that acquisition, which finalized in November 2024, CSG has the leverage to prioritize arming the United States' enemies over the US military if it benefits them politically or financially.

Some of the same people may still work in the US based facilities but it's not the same Federal Premium that one may have done business with a year ago, or in the past.

As for the cartridge. Maybe the obviously paid for gun tuber and writer shills can prop it up?
 
Top