5 "Dont's" I learned becoming an Elk hunter...by Luke Stephens

Joined
Mar 18, 2020
Messages
1
***** Disclaimer - I by no means consider myself an expert Elk hunter. I am am an east coaster who, decided to take it up 7 years ago when the Montana lottery shifted in favor of out-of-staters. I also am fortunate and give a lot of credit to having a brother who had been elk hunting for years and is a Montana resident.

That said, I also feel like for someone who went from absolutely no knowledge of Elk hunting, that I have done a decent job of bagging elk 4/5 years I have hunted them - albeit I only have 3 nice bulls on my wall, as the 4th was poached out from under me.

Consider this newbie advice and insight. If you are a serious, long-term elk hunter I will try to make you laugh - so that at least you will get something out of it.

Don't 1 - Don't have herd lust.

In places like the Yellowstone basin it can be hard not to develop herd lust. What is herd lust? That's when you see those 500+, 1000+ herds that sit on private land (mostly) and tease you by occasionally crossing into public land. Yep those herds.

Those herds that tease and mock you - and 10,000 other hunters like you trying to "be there" when they put that 1 toe (um hoof) on public land and you get your chance.

Look I hunt them, now - sometimes, like everyone else. But if you become fixated on them just know you are better off playing the lottery. Nearly every elk I and my brother have killed (except 1) have come from smaller pods and herds.

When you are consumed with herd lust you stop hunting the elk you can more likely kill.

These days my brother and I limit our "herd lust" outings to maybe opening day or an occasional late season hail mary after the hunting is dying down. Otherwise, while we may "check on them" - we don't hunt them. We use them to gauge what the smaller pods may be doing.

Don't 2 - Don't ever assume the weather will be what you think or plan.

Wow, from finding the elk to just surviving, weather during elk season seems the most fickle and wide ranging I have ever seen. Don't assume because the weather is suppose to be X that when you get to your hunting spot it is going to be anything like that. This past year during one of our herd lust days (opening day) we sat out in weather that went from foggy, to freezing to, a down pour, to freezing... All of which had not been projected. And quite frankly made our day a total bust. The fog alone would have ruined it as you could not see 5'.

Since we were on a plain that we had hiked over 3 miles to get into - our options were zero for changing it. We had to sit through total weather misery and just hope for an act of mercy. It didn't come.

With elk hunting have several location options for any place you want to hunt. Altitude options (to get above/below mist/fog lines); terrain options to accommodate winds, rain, etc.... just have several options in mind. Before you commit to a single weather option terrain be damn sure you - otherwise you will blow a day of hunting.

Don't 3 - Don't get stuck in 1 mode of hunting.

Whether you like spot and stalk, run and gun, still hunting.... Don't get stuck in 1 mode. My brother and I are a good team. He is the "ants in his pants" type of hunter. I on the other hand will sit and watch and listen an entire day. We compliment each other, both in the field and in our styles. I slow him down and he speeds me up. We break each other out of modes that may not be working.

If you don't have a partner that can help do that, go into a hunting situation with a plan and hard stops that will force you to change you mode. For instance, if you are spot and stalk type of guy... Then give yourself 1 day and if you don't see elk like you want to kill, become mobile and do quicker spot and stalk variants until you do... Then resume your style full bore.

I highly, though, will encourage all of you to find a/some complimentary hunting partners - they help your knowledge grow and make you see your hunting differently.

Don't 4 - Don't carry the kitchen sink.

My first years hunting elk, I am pretty sure I figured out a way to carry 90lbs in a 1800 cu in pack. I had enough extra blades for my knife for an entire lifetime in my pack. Or spare batteries to survive the zombie apocalypse. I carried stuff that looking back - am not really sure why it even got on the plane with me.

A truism for my elk hunting is to be successful you have to be highly mobile and nimble. You can't be either if you are carrying tons of gear. Much less when you have to pack an elk (or even large deer) out - that gear does you abso-freaking-lutely nothing to help. Constantly trim down your kit. Even with a trimmed down kit, ask yourself each outing if you need everything you are carrying.

Essentials: Killing machine (that includes the projectile parts), grey matter, reasonable clothing to survive the variable conditions (note I said survive, not love), knife (plus stone or blades).

Non essential (buy may need): Water, Food, compass/gps (not always folks... I know some land well enough I am fine going geo-commando), phone, rope, bugle (not always)

If you are backpack or deep terrain hunting of course the essentials and non change. Just keep it light and nimble.

Don't 5 - Don't ever think you can't, won't or they aren't

Don't ever think you can't elk hunt an area. I have been in some deep, steep, fallen timber; scrabble gorges, etc and if I thought I "can't" for a second I can count 2 of my 4 elk as not happening.

Don't ever think you won't find elk in an area or they aren't there. This past season, the elk I killed was in a place I would have never thought them to be - and one that I had driven by a 100 times and never seen the elk that were in there.

I could go on for days about the can't's won't's and aren't's. The bottom line with elk hunting you have to believe and hunt hard to be a good elk hunter.

Pep talk aside let me say being a flat lander the first year in Montana was daunting. There are places I would go that I thought "hell no" I am never hunting in there again - they beat me up so bad. With time and experience (and training) I now kick their asses and take names. You will too. Just keep the faith.

Well I said 5, so there are my 5. I hope this helps some aspiring or new elk hunters. Those of you who are tried and true, well hope you chuckled.

Luke Stephens aka Wilderness Master
 

Shotshill

FNG
Joined
Jun 22, 2019
Messages
84
To the Safety Nazis Gods of Rokslide...
I humble seek forgiveness from you and submit myself for penitence for allowing my tactical skills honed through years of training and operations to lift my unloaded and bolt open weapon in the direction, from on your high throne, you deem wrongful or unsafe. I submit in my defense the bullets whizzing over my head and also in the direction of my beloved brother caused my law enforcement trained mind to need to ascertain the intent of those persons, as well as at least get some basic descriptions - in case I (or my brother) were harmed. I also request to reduce my punishment for my having the calm state of mind to ensure the gun would not be able to fire accidentally - even though that could have put my life in more jeopardy had the intent of those shooters been to kill me. I ask that your duly noted tongue lashing and an ice cold bath (I shall take tonight if it please you) suffice as said penitence. Forevermore should someone shoot at me or in my direction I will not defend myself nor even cause them any risk by raising anything but a glass of beer in their direction.

To Mr "up a creek sans paddle" guy...
Pleeeeeeeze. Since I have had way too many guns pointed at me intent on doing me harm, and some of those have fired projectiles in my direction, let me suggest it is a waste of your last minutes and options to save your arse to even consider any "up a creek option". I highly encourage the options you choose at that moment in time to be: a) get down b) if you feel your life is in immediate jeopardy to "talk your way out of it". The false bravado of any "cllint eastwood are you feeling lucky" move is scientifically proven to be wasted activity given it takes less than .25 of a second for the brain to cause the body to pull a trigger - and anything under 500 yards will hit its target in less than .75 of a second (rifle wise). So unless you can react to this threat, get your gun ready, aim it on target (probably at a distance), and command your brain to pull the trigger all well under 1 second then your "I am badder than you" thinking is going to get you killed. If you can do all that under 1 sec., I offer two suggestions: a) even trying to do so against somebody already aiming at you at best may result in a draw b) you should be a professional shooter and are probably not human. But maybe stupid brave works stops bullets - I haven't tried lately.

If this is RokSlides way of voting people off the island, no need to I will happily leave. Just have the kahunas to send me a private message and vote me off. I am hear to positively and with some fun share some stories and knowledge. I tried to provide some clues to the drive by snipers that I am not incompetent, evil or immoral, but clearly they need firmer encouragement than clues. I do not have time to both contribute reasonable posts and deal with people who assume the worst/evil/incompetent in others just to get the attention they can't get otherwise. Just let me know.

I stand by what I did. Would do it again. You probably would to. Period. Get the Freak over it.
Im with the SF on this... Roger that and Hooah brother!
 

Mr. W

FNG
Joined
Jun 10, 2020
Messages
20
I enjoyed your post and if in the same situation would probably do the same thing.
 
Joined
Feb 17, 2013
Messages
2,339
Do not try to fit an elk hunt into one week. It’s a 2 week thing if you want to get there, set camp, work out the aches, pains, and acclimation, find the elk, get an opportunity, kill one.... and pack it out.
 

luckydraw2014

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
May 23, 2019
Messages
154
Location
McHenry IL
Hey Wildernessmaster... you may want to reconsider your user name.

Even most beginners know that pointing your rifle (especially loaded) at someone so you can view them through your scope is especially stupid and dangerous.

I recall a Johnny Cash song......
 

Maverick1

WKR
Joined
Jun 1, 2013
Messages
1,837
Luke Stephens aka Wilderness Master

Nice posts. Sounds like some interesting adventures. Congratulations on your success, sounds like you are having a great time, too.

Question: in addition to being an elk hunter, are you also a fisherman?
 

Reburn

Mayhem Contributor
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
3,425
Location
Central Texas
Another @wildernessmaster missed animal. Well technically it could be called a hit...a wounding. Glad the animal was finished off.

Then a scoping.....what a jerk move. Scoping people isn't cool. Isn't the first rule of firearm safety that a gun is always loaded? Or did they not teach you that with your extensive special forces and law enforcement training.......

Was particularly funny you taking pictures of a loaded 9mm ar on your bench to sell.

Gold standard gun safety there.

Screenshot (75).png
 
Last edited:
OP
wildernessmaster

wildernessmaster

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
May 12, 2020
Messages
297
Location
Pittsboro NC
Another @wildernessmaster missed animal. Well technically it could be called a hit...a wounding. Glad the animal was finished off.

Then a scoping.....what a jerk move. Scoping people isn't cool. Isn't the first rule of firearm safety that a gun is always loaded? Or did they not teach you that with your extensive special forces and law enforcement training.......

Was particularly funny you taking pictures of a loaded 9mm ar on your bench to sell.

Gold standard gun safety there.
man you must have put your panties on backwards today... but again thank you for reading!
 
Top