.223 for bear, mountain goat, deer, elk, and moose.

[ElPollo]

I didn't read all 463 pages of this thread.

On page 1, the OP wrote "Based on my sample of one, the 77 TMK out of a .223 is truly a lethal combination well suited to a dedicated lower 48 big game rifle."

I saw further posts showing pictures of animals killed with .223s.

Yes, if all things are perfect, a .223 will kill any of the animals that he listed.

I've had friends that used their .22-250 or .220 Swift to kill a black bear every year, multiple elk, 3 mountain goats that I knew of, and at least 4 buffalo. They were all excellent shooters, and they only talked about the animals that they had killed, they never said much about the ones that they wounded and got away.

My Eskimo guide on my Musk ox hunt told me he killed a polar bear with his .223. When I asked him how many shots it took, he just smiled.

I have 2 rifles chambered in .223, and another in .22-250 that I used to make one shot kills on at least 4 deer and pronghorn antelope. I have also killed around a dozen deer with a .22 LR (and not wounded or lost any), but I don't recommend it as a deer cartridge either.

I have also successfully DIY hunted all of the animals listed in the OP's first post, so my opinion is based on my first hand experiences and not on internet posts. Many new and inexperienced hunters look to the internet for advice for their own hunting.

Not all shots in hunting situations are perfect, and I hate to see animals being wounded and suffer after being shot, so I stand by my opinion that a .223 is lethal, but it is NOT truly well suited to a dedicated lower 48 big game rifle.


So can I only repy if I agree with the OP's post?

.223 for bear, mountain goat, deer, elk, and moose.

I have not become a Kool-Aid drinker, but I am willing to tasted test. 1) Tikka T3X in 223 2) Starline Brass + 69g TMk bullets Anything else I need to test the Kool-Aid? I have Tallley Rings. For now, it has a Leupold VX-Freedom. It will do until I decide what kind of scope I really want...

rokslide.com

 

[fwafwow]

I didn't read all 463 pages of this thread.

Maybe another way to say what some others have said - this thread has been going on for a while. Some of us joined late (myself included), starting with various beliefs, and some of us have changed our views. But irrespective of whether some have, or haven't, changed their views - there's a history and custom (IMHO) in this thread, and others - in that many have been following it and read through the various back and forth points/arguments/counterpoints, etc.

So if you post in a substantive manner, or even with an opinion, and you haven't read the thread, you don't know that you are making some of the arguments that have been made previously in this thread. Sometimes on multiple occasions.

As the OP said - read up (it takes a while), then let us know what you think. If you still disagree, that's of course fine, but you can then narrow your response.

 

[Schmo]

The 223 with 77TMK is sooo marginal for deer, I think I’ll use it again.

353 yards. Bang flop.

Entrance side -



No exit, blew through off side rub and stopped under skin -

 

[MEdude]

Pretty stoked, this is my first harvest of any kind and second year out hunting.
73 Eldm from 1-7 16”
20 yards and dropped

CONGRATS from the Midcoast! Nice deer.

Curious, “20 yard and dropped”, does that mean a 20 yard shot and dropped on the spot? Or a shot at some other distance, and ran 20 yards?

 

[MEwaters]

CONGRATS from the Midcoast! Nice deer.

Curious, “20 yard and dropped”, does that mean a 20 yard shot and dropped on the spot? Or a shot at some other distance, and ran 20 yards?

Where do you consider midcoast? Got it out off route 9. Monsters out there where I hunt but I took first opportunity today given kids and wife etc lol.
I hit it at about 40 yards. Sprinted right at me darted into pine thicket and died after about a 20 yard run

 

[MEdude]

midcoast

Thomaston area.
You out on the airline? I lived in Calais for a couple years.

 

[MEwaters]

Thomaston area.
You out on the airline? I lived in Calais for a couple years.

I hunt off airline but live in Bangor area. My best friend grew up in Thomason, lives in that same area now. I enjoy it there

 

[SURVEYOR]

Here’s a 77 TMK kill my boy made last night. I’ve killed a few hundred hogs and deer with 223s, mostly hogs. Approximately 1/2 were shot with cheap 55 grain soft points and 1/2 55grain FMJ. If you hit bone with an FMJ it’s usually a bullet tumble and lights out, no bone and it’s more trigger time. I’ve also shot 2 deer with Barnes and was very disappointed in the wound size. However I have used the 64 grain Winchester on 3-4 deer and it worked very well. This was a high shoulder at 150 so this doe flopped over. We need to shoot a few more before forming an opinion on the 77s. The Jagd Terrier was disappointed that it was just a dead deer and no blood trail.