.223 for bear, mountain goat, deer, elk, and moose.

OP
P

PNWGATOR

WKR
Shoot2HuntU
Joined
Oct 14, 2014
Messages
2,735
Location
USA
Don’t over complicate things. Load the bullet at mag length at/near max pressure and go shoot. Gas or bolt gun, doesn’t matter.
 

kevlar88

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Nov 19, 2018
Messages
229
Location
Hawaii/Texas/Germany
IMG_5048.jpg
I told myself I'd never shoot another animal with a 223 after the complete failure of a bullet using factory 55 grain GECO ballistic tip on a small 50 pound roe deer. After seeing some of the reports here I figured I'd give the 77tmk a go on a pig and as you can see it worked on this 95+- pound sow that didn't take another step after the shot. Hit highish shoulder, went through the scapula, knocked out a 1.5" section of rib and completely shredded the lungs (chunks were coming out of the entrance rib after the shoulder was removed). To my surprise there was actually enough bullet still intact for an exit between two ribs and through the opposite scapula. Shot was right at 100 yards so impact velocity was somewhere in the neighborhood of 2650 fps. I will try them again, hopefully on a larger boar to see how it handles a thick shield.
66767852738__83C21F74-08BF-416E-BDC2-A5FDA3F5CC46.jpg She made good Brats.
 
Joined
Aug 23, 2014
Messages
5,340
Location
oregon coast
View attachment 387007
I told myself I'd never shoot another animal with a 223 after the complete failure of a bullet using factory 55 grain GECO ballistic tip on a small 50 pound roe deer. After seeing some of the reports here I figured I'd give the 77tmk a go on a pig and as you can see it worked on this 95+- pound sow that didn't take another step after the shot. Hit highish shoulder, went through the scapula, knocked out a 1.5" section of rib and completely shredded the lungs (chunks were coming out of the entrance rib after the shoulder was removed). To my surprise there was actually enough bullet still intact for an exit between two ribs and through the opposite scapula. Shot was right at 100 yards so impact velocity was somewhere in the neighborhood of 2650 fps. I will try them again, hopefully on a larger boar to see how it handles a thick shield.
View attachment 387014 She made good Brats.
Heck yeah! Sounds like great performance all around 👍
 

URE_G

FNG
Joined
Oct 19, 2021
Messages
51
Most bullet work well when properly placed. Barnes work great as does the 77 grain SMK
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2021
Messages
1,553
No heartburn there. I would ask how many animals you've taken with Barnes bullets that have given a narrow wound channel? Everything (elk, muley's, pronghorn) with a .270 Win, '06 or 35 Whelen AI I've shot in the last 12 years with a TTSX is anything but narrow. Not pulp soup like the fast expanding bullets that destroy meat but a dead animal that had its vitals destroyed in a way no reasonable person would say was narrow. To each his own based on experience.

Seriously, I feel bullets don't contaminate meat to any large extent however I don't know a person that knowingly eats lead... sounds like more than a perceived narrow wound channel is at play here. Regardless of whether a mono or lead bullet is the best for the job at hand you show Utah as your location, why reference California and give a crap about what goes on there? I don't.
 
Last edited:

Shraggs

WKR
Joined
Jan 24, 2014
Messages
1,589
Location
Zeeland, MI
The spirit of this thread isn’t a 223 caliber head stamp, it’s the wounding of tmks and how an explosive wounding Bullet can dramatically elevate a punny 22 cal to take large game and what most would consider medium to long range.

35w if you can produce photos if 55 grain tsx in a 223 in dead elk at 450 yards were all ears.

35 caliber w tsx don’t count in this thread.
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2021
Messages
1,553
When the bullet doesn't fly apart it doesn't contaminate to any large extent therefore I feel that is true. Some folks definition of what constitutes contamination (degree of) is different than others. Making sure I own what I say and let other people feel and think what they want.

Thanks for calling me out on the 223 element. 35's don't play! Wrong subject matter.

As far as effectiveness of Barnes bullets, they are effective. Nothing ineffective about cup and core either, different ways to the same end. I digressed and my bad.

Carry on, I enjoy reading about a very different perspective on how effective these projectiles are/can be.
 

Moose83

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Aug 30, 2020
Messages
289
So... if given the choice between a Hornady 55gr spire point or a 73gr eld-m what would be your choice for spring black bear. I haven't read this thread for a while but if I remember correctly the 73 gr was a bit splashy up close while the 55 gr has a proven reputation in close on other forums. Still trying to find reasonably priced 77 tmk's here in Canada so that's off the table for now. Thanks!
 

Te Hopo

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
196
Location
New Zealand
So... if given the choice between a Hornady 55gr spire point or a 73gr eld-m what would be your choice for spring black bear. I haven't read this thread for a while but if I remember correctly the 73 gr was a bit splashy up close while the 55 gr has a proven reputation in close on other forums. Still trying to find reasonably priced 77 tmk's here in Canada so that's off the table for now. Thanks!
I've never used the 73eldm but I do have a lot of experience with the 55sp for pest control on hogs and red deer

I'm very confident in it, put one in the chest and it'll likely make it out the other side after busting ribs, punching through lungs and heart.
I have recovered a few projectiles under the offside skin and they were perfect mushrooms
 

jadkins223

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jan 21, 2022
Messages
115
Location
Oklahoma
So... if given the choice between a Hornady 55gr spire point or a 73gr eld-m what would be your choice for spring black bear. I haven't read this thread for a while but if I remember correctly the 73 gr was a bit splashy up close while the 55 gr has a proven reputation in close on other forums. Still trying to find reasonably priced 77 tmk's here in Canada so that's off the table for now. Thanks!

I’m hoping 73s do good because I have 300 of them haha! Going 2820 fps with tac out of my ruger predator 223


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

JBradley500

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Feb 15, 2020
Messages
292
Please update with the 73 elds because I have a couple hundred and I'm not sure if I'd want to deer hunt with them because I get most shots within 25 yards.
 

clperry

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Dec 5, 2019
Messages
257
Please update with the 73 elds because I have a couple hundred and I'm not sure if I'd want to deer hunt with them because I get most shots within 25 yards.

At 25 yards, put it in the neck or behind an ear and it won’t matter what bullet you’re using.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Jim1187

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 7, 2020
Messages
214
Location
New Brunswick, Canada
So... if given the choice between a Hornady 55gr spire point or a 73gr eld-m what would be your choice for spring black bear. I haven't read this thread for a while but if I remember correctly the 73 gr was a bit splashy up close while the 55 gr has a proven reputation in close on other forums. Still trying to find reasonably priced 77 tmk's here in Canada so that's off the table for now. Thanks!
I don't have any experience first hand with the 73 ELD-m, however I have used the .223 and Hornady's 55 grain sp w/c for a couple. Neither where particularly close or large bears( both around 100 yards and between 200 and 230lbs). If you're talking eating sized bears I'd use the 55 again and probably will because they shoot well in most .22 centerfires and are cheap and readily available, but I'd prefer a Speer Golddot, Nosler Partition or Swift Sirocco based on my experiences.
If you can find TMK's in Canada at any price currently you're doing well. I occasionally see the 60's but I don't know if they have the same performance of the 69 and 77.
 
Top