If you like the way Slick Tricks fly just get a Stay Sharp guide to really sharpen the blades before hunting. Pretty simple and quick technique.I recently got back into bowhunting last year.
This year, I arrowed a nice eight at eleven yards at a hard downward angle, slight quarter towards me. Slick Trick standard 100 grain. Complete pass through (and I'm only shooting 52# out of my Mathews Image).
Very little to no blood trail. He stopped and laid down about fifty yards distant for about ten minutes then got back up and walked off. Only blood was where he had been laying (and not much there) and a few drops afterwards. Searched for hours that night and again in the morning. Honestly thought I muscle hit him.
Found him two days later after smelling him from the house. Double lunged him. He ended up running about 100 yards as the crow flies. I was sick. There just wasn't enough blood to track. I'm not saying it was 100% the Slick Trick head, but I would have expected more blood.
To me, it doesn't seem as if these replaceable blade heads are as sharp as they used to be. Maybe it's a liability issue, I don't know. But when I was hitting it hard in the late 90's, early 2000's, I was almost afraid to swap blades in my Muzzy heads--they were like scalpels. I cut myself more than once.
Case in point, I just ordered a set of heads off of this company called "Exact Archery". I liked the blade design (sturdy, replaceable blades, cut on impact) so I thought I'd give them a shot. I can run my fingers up and down the blades without cutting myself. Rough machining marks on the blades. Pathetic. Tossed them in the trash.
I don't trust mechanicals because of the low poundage, and even they're not impressively sharp. Seen a set of Sevr heads my buddy bought--same thing. Not sharp a