I don't agree about the anti-Roth regardless if you're going heavy into RE. It's only $6500/year. Most serious FIRE guys can probably come up with that and why not go ahead and have those nice tax fee earnings when they turn 59.5. FIRE guys want to live that long too. Use multiple financial vehicles to fund your long retirement. I don't think you have to be anti Roth when you're talking FIRE and super confident in all that easy RE money.
I completely understand what you're saying.
Main point of this thread was getting to financial independence/retirement as early as possible.
Tying money up in a Roth isn't the play for that. I'll add some long-winded details below to help guys that might be following along willing to entertain both approaches:
For a young investor that same $6,500, or a couple years worth of it in an expensive market, could be used to get into a 3.5% down FHA loan on an owner-occupied 4-plex (or duplex, or triplex, or sfr where you rent the rooms, doesn't matter). Legally required to live there for a year, during that time you'd be getting paid to live there and increasing your net earnings and reducing your DTI.
Now you have more income freed up to buy a) a nicer place to live b) qualify for more investment properties c) stick more money into other investment vehicles. This stuff snowballs fast because of leverage...I know, that's a dirty word for some.
The same advantages of a Roth exist in real estate. Each property is a mini-bank that you can take tax-free withdrawals from (within reason). A bank will lend up to 80% LTV on just about any piece of real estate in the country that isn't a POS. Run your worst case scenario numbers for potential corrections, stick to them, cash out that tax free money and go buy more. Don't use it to buy a truck, boat, etc. early on.
If you have enough principal in your Roth, it'll replenish itself after a withdrawal...when you're 60. Cool.
If you have a good equity position in a property, your tenants will replenish that position post re-fi. Any equity pulled is still tax free money because it's either a loan or line of credit....but now you can double dip on depreciation, claim real estate professional status, a whole slew of write-offs etc. that do not exist in the world of Roth IRAs.
Most folks will/should eventually pay a handful of properties off in-full as a security blanket, but aggressive growth is ALWAYS done with leverage. Whether that's bank money, other people's money, etc.
The tax rules are there to be taken advantage of, and if a fella was focused on speed...the trajectory through various types of real estate investing is exponentially faster than playing the long game.
When you take into account the fact that there is an estimated 4 MILLION unit shortage in housing in this country TODAY...you can see the opportunity for what it is...and there is a reason institutional money (hedge funds, family offices etc) are scooping resi. at unprecedented rates...
I don't believe that real estate is the holy grail for financial independence because I'm in real estate, I'm in real estate because I know it's the holy grail for financial independence. Big difference.
I'll leave that as my last contribution to this thread, if it helps one guy hunt more and spend more time with his family...worth the 5 minutes it took to type it up.
And if any of you know of any RV or mobile home parks in a red state that may be for sale...hit me up, and I'll make sure you're paid a handsome bird dog fee.