I still love my Altra Lone Peaks and Altra Superiors. I have a variety of gaiters that I wear with them depending on conditions and waterproof socks inside of them if needed.
I've had both and one thing I've noticed on the Altra shoes, their soles suck when its wet outside. They need to do some serious R&D on their soles. That being said, they are coming out with a Lone Peak Mid this year to compete with the Hoka Tor Ultra Mid ( I think that's the one). If it doesn't have a vibram sole on it I'm not even going to consider it, that's how much I dislike their stock soles. Otherwise I like their stuff, but durability isn't quite up to par either.