What temp range do you switch to a heated shelter?

My hunting group does a lot of backpacking in the off-season and it's very rare to see a stove in that setting but becoming almost essential gear to many of the other hunt camps around us. I think you learn things backpacking that really apply to lightweight hunt camping and it's been hard for us to adopt many of the changes (mostly additional gear) modern hunters have made common.

To be fair to the situation of hunting vs general backpacking, I too do quite a bit of backpacking, usually 25-35 nights worth across the summer with at least some of those nights out overlapping with the same general area that I elk hunt in. I go through my core elk hunting area in, say, late July, and there are backpackers galore, sometimes at a rate of encountering people on the trail every 5 minutes. However, when I go into this area in October, its very rare to see any backpackers at all. I see the occasional highly experienced climbing group who are backpacking in, but only on very moderate weather years and that's still the exception by far. Chances are, if I do see another group, they are goat hunters.

The reality is, there just aren't many backpackers camping out at 11,000 feet in October and, if they are, they typically aren't getting up at 3:30 in the morning and staying out and about until dark, returning to camp 1-2+ hours after dark. Beyond that, if they are out that time of year, they aren't staying out for 7-10+ days and even if they are, they often aren't intentionally out in wet weather, particularly for consecutive days. So, a hot tent takes on a bit of a different role for hunters vs backpackers.

By comparison, hot tents are becoming increasingly popular for backcountry skiers who like to camp in the backcountry which makes total sense: elevation, winter, cold, snow, stuff to dry out. But, I wouldn't concern myself with the standards of backpacking applying to mountain hunting in Oct and Nov anymore than I would apply the standards of ultralight backpacking weights to the weight of backpack hunting.
 
For me, it really only has to do with location. If I am truck camping, I will almost always have my heated shelter in the fall/winter. I may not start the fire each night but it is nice to have the option.

If I am backpack hunting or setting up a spike camp, I will usually just use a small, light, unheated tent. It can suck. But so can carrying a stove and looking for wood...
 
Like others, my decision is based on potential need to dry out and how many hours I'll be in camp.

Sept archery I just want to go to sleep when get back after dark, and wake as late as possible when getting up before first light. If at the truck though, a buddy heater is sweet for a quick warm up for getting up and dressing or before bed.

When I'm in the tent for hours after dark and before sleep, then a heater/stove is a very nice luxury.
 
I will take the stove when I know my water is going to freeze and it will be difficult to unthaw. Typically that is when it stays below freezing all day and single digits at night. For you guys who are camping without heat below 0 how are you keeping your water from freezing? Are you sleeping with it in your bag or something else?
 
It depends; I've hunted cool weather where I came back to camp totally worn out, with all my body's fuel burnt up. I'd eat, but my body is still not putting out body heat, despite being in a good, typically warm sleeping bag/quilt, and have slept like crap, because I never warmed up. A tent heat source simply preheat me and my sleep system, and ensures I sleep well. If the wind is howling and cold, to well below freezing, dry or not, a heat source is a need. I've spent a week in temps that never came close to getting above -20, with 60 MPH sustained winds and stronger gusts, without a heat source other than a jet boil. My buddy and I both lost about 25 pounds each. If it's a quick weekend trip, I'll suffer without a heat source if it makes sense to me, maybe up to 4 days. After that, I want a heat source

The problem with a heat source, is it makes it soooooo much more comfortable, that you will start to want it, even when you don't really need it. It's just nice to take the chill out of the air as you're sitting getting ready, eating dinner or breakfast...
 
Back
Top