I was going to say my Schnee's Beartooth boots have treated me well. I've used them for 4 years over multiple hunts and never had a leaking issue. I did forget gaiters on a trip and my socks wicked moisture into my boot.You are correct to mention wearing gaiters as I think many people have moisture come down the pant/sock and blame the boot. Also, I think a lot of people sweat in their boot and don't realize the moisture is from sweat.
I have been happy with my Schnees Beartooths, but I have taken great care of them (conditioning, cleaning, etc). I have had bad experiences with Crispis and water.