Yah, *zap* this is a great point that is often missed. You need to define “fitness” for yourself. Rippetoe makes an argument for strength being the end-all-be-all. He’s getting up there in age (maybe 60??) and can still deadlift 600, and regularly squats 500. He is self admittedly fluffy but he also argues that having some excess BF% is not a bad thing.
Me personally, I take what anyone says with a grain of salt and run it through my own judgement and set of goals. Strength is not the only goal I have, and I suspect all others on RK would agree that climbing the mountain for days on end is just as important. But I also can’t argue that being strong makes one better in all areas. I recommend starting with getting measurably stronger and then adding in the conditioning and other things to meet your own goals.
JStol5, glad you got the book. Read it. Pay attention to the definition of a novice and the linear progression that is laid out. I did a NLP in my mid 40s and got to be the strongest I’ve even been, and I was a collegiate athlete. I stopped doing any formal training a few years after that because of a divorce and then covid. At the beginning of this year I’ve started a NLP progression again, I’m 52 and I’m progressing on the program exactly as written and the results are exactly as predicted. The program works and is THE best way to put on measurable strength in a relatively short time.
Appreciate the response, I'm excited to get it. I have chronic tightness though and my goal is to get stronger without hurting myself, hence the dedicated yoga/mobility work.