Vivo forest tracker esc durability

dtrkyman

WKR
Joined
Oct 2, 2014
Messages
3,169
Received today, fit seems spot on with a 10, I normally go 9.5 in most shoes.

So less than a week to receive.
 
Last edited:

joshr

FNG
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
18
Location
Australia
As much as I love the Tracker ESC’s for hiking and backcountry use, I don’t find them great for an everyday shoe around town and for work. Taking them on and off is a bit of a chore and getting the uppers laced perfectly so that they don’t pinch can be tricky.

Enter the Magna Leather FG. This thing is the most comfortable shoe I’ve worn. They slip on easily, without untying. the sole is plenty grippy enough for everyday use on gravel, dirt, grass. The leather is even higher quality than the Trackers ESC’s and waterproof.

5/5 Highly recommend.

View attachment 710008
View attachment 710009View attachment 710010View attachment 710011


My vivo Primus has those soles on them and man, they can be slick.

Planning on going to the Forests however was worried about slipping around on them here in the coastal jungle/clay soil. Reading through this post, looks like I may need to pay attention to foot placement.
 
Joined
Jun 20, 2024
Messages
17
Had concerns initially, but reading this thread sold me. Pulled the trigger on some Forest ESCs last night
 

Lawnboi

WKR
Joined
Mar 2, 2012
Messages
8,348
Location
North Central Wi
I got a pair of the magna FG for work, since they are all black.

Slightly prefer the forest trackers, that tread does seem to give them a little extra cushion. But the fg are not terrible, and they grip adequately for what I’m using them for.

They do fit a hair more snug than the tracker but not by much, I’m wearing the same size. They do seem like they are going to last longer as a station/ems shoe.


I’m just finally getting to the point that I don’t feel worn out in my feet after a few days of constant wear. And I’m coming from wearing altras and inov8 for years. My body feels better wearing these shoes now.

No durability issues yet 6 months in, but at 150 I’m not very rough on shoes to begin with.


Has anyone spent a decent amount of time in the prairie with these? I’m taking them antelope hunting this fall, just worried that I’m going to puncture the sole potentially with cacti
 
Joined
Oct 6, 2014
Messages
1,882
Location
Wasilla, Alaska
My vivo Primus has those soles on them and man, they can be slick.

Planning on going to the Forests however was worried about slipping around on them here in the coastal jungle/clay soil. Reading through this post, looks like I may need to pay attention to foot placement.
That terrain sounds challenging for any sole! The Forest ESC's would probably be better suited in that case, or atleast the Magna ESC's.
 

Formidilosus

Super Moderator
Shoot2HuntU
Joined
Oct 22, 2014
Messages
9,922
Has anyone spent a decent amount of time in the prairie with these? I’m taking them antelope hunting this fall, just worried that I’m going to puncture the sole potentially with cacti

Lots. Have not had a complete puncture of the sole- lots stuck in them and broken, but nothing has made it into the foot area. They specifically are my prairie and cactus shoe.
 

2buffalo

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 4, 2022
Messages
176
Lots. Have not had a complete puncture of the sole- lots stuck in them and broken, but nothing has made it into the foot area. They specifically are my prairie and cactus shoe.
How do these work for someone who has had several ankle injuries (weak ligaments)?
 

BBob

WKR
Joined
Jun 29, 2020
Messages
4,403
Location
Southern AZ
How do these work for someone who has had several ankle injuries (weak ligaments)?
I'm of the opinion that rather than continually trying to support a weak ankle thats suffered injury is to give it time to get strong by not supporting (pampering) the weak ankle. After the injury yeah maybe support it some so you can walk but for the long term let it strengthen itself. BTW yes I have suffered a pretty severe ankle injury (broken bones, blasted ligaments). My ankle will never be the same as it once was but I have no real issues with it and I can wear pretty much a no support shoe about anywhere. It did take time though.
 

2buffalo

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Mar 4, 2022
Messages
176
I figures with less sole/heel height it should be better kinda like I don't have a real issue turning my ankles in cross but have to wear an ASO in hiking boots or I do roll it. I have had bad ankles since playing sports in high school.
 

Lawnboi

WKR
Joined
Mar 2, 2012
Messages
8,348
Location
North Central Wi
How do these work for someone who has had several ankle injuries (weak ligaments)?
Given time to adapt to a minimal boot I think they are the best option. That said that can take years.

I had very weak ankles that I tried to mask with heavy boots. Swapped to minimalist shoes and a lot of trail running and that pretty much disappeared, even with that I wouldn’t jump into a hunting with these boots without some serious training of your feet/body.
 

dtrkyman

WKR
Joined
Oct 2, 2014
Messages
3,169
Training on a Bosu ball with bare feet with help with ankle and foot strength/stability.

Just switched to Vivo, no issues for me but no hard miles yet either, chickened out trying them on a backpack fishing trip last week, camped 10 miles deep and carried 30lbs, after the trip I wished I tried the vivo as my previous boots have had it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Ram94

WKR
Joined
Jul 24, 2019
Messages
657
Has anyone taken these on a sheep hunt yet? I’m on board with idea especially for high mileage on trail, or soft ground off trail, just hesitant on the performance while climbing/descending actual mountain terrain. Thinking basketball sized boulder fields where your feet regularly get rolled onto. These seem like they wouldn’t have enough protection.
 

BBob

WKR
Joined
Jun 29, 2020
Messages
4,403
Location
Southern AZ
Has anyone taken these on a sheep hunt yet? I’m on board with idea especially for high mileage on trail, or soft ground off trail, just hesitant on the performance while climbing/descending actual mountain terrain. Thinking basketball sized boulder fields where your feet regularly get rolled onto. These seem like they wouldn’t have enough protection.
Sheep hunt? No but equal to or worse rock conditions. I’m not worrying about “feet rolling” or protection from rock they do fine by me there. What I don’t like is the ESC soles do not have the grip on rock as compared to a traditional Vibram like sole you’ll find on most boots. On technical rock I wouldn’t have them. I’ve tried but they can get sketchy. A buddy won’t wear any of his Vivo’s anymore where there’s going to be any technical rock either. This includes the smoothish sole material on the Gobi, no bueno on rock. So if you anticipate having to negotiate a bunch of technical rock then I wouldn’t wear them. If it’s scrambling dry boulder fields then I might be okay with it depending on the rock.

I’m thinking the Jim Green’s are going to be better for this. I still need more rock time in them.
 
Last edited:

Ram94

WKR
Joined
Jul 24, 2019
Messages
657
Sheep hunt? No but equal to or worse rock conditions. I’m not worrying about “feet rolling” or protection from rock they do fine by me there. What I don’t like is the ESC soles do not have the grip on rock as compared to a traditional Vibram like sole you’ll find on most boots. On technical rock I wouldn’t have them. I’ve tried but they can get sketchy. A buddy won’t wear any of his Vivo’s anymore where there’s going to be any technical rock either. This includes the smoothish sole material on the Gobi, no bueno on rock. So if you anticipate having to negotiate a bunch of technical rock then I wouldn’t wear them. If it’s scrambling dry boulder fields then I might be okay with it depending on the rock.

I’m thinking the Jim Green’s are going to be better for this. I still need more rock time in them.
Thank you for sharing! I’ll probably go with my gut and stick with my Scarpas.
 

BBob

WKR
Joined
Jun 29, 2020
Messages
4,403
Location
Southern AZ
Thank you for sharing! I’ll probably go with my gut and stick with my Scarpas.
That’s exactly what I do. I have a pair of Scarpa’s that get called up when needed. I don’t wear them much anymore but they’re the right tool for some things :)
 

Bsnyder

WKR
Joined
Feb 14, 2018
Messages
465
How do these work for someone who has had several ankle injuries (weak ligaments)?
I was in the same boat as you went zero show haven’t had an ankle issue since. I jumped straight in and did 7 miles in my zero shoes day one. Did my feet hurt no. Tired yes hurt no. They are my favorite shoes. They will make your ankles stronger at least that was my experience.
 

Formidilosus

Super Moderator
Shoot2HuntU
Joined
Oct 22, 2014
Messages
9,922
Has anyone taken these on a sheep hunt yet? I’m on board with idea especially for high mileage on trail, or soft ground off trail, just hesitant on the performance while climbing/descending actual mountain terrain. Thinking basketball sized boulder fields where your feet regularly get rolled onto. These seem like they wouldn’t have enough protection.


IMG_9803.jpeg
 
Top