How much brass do you have? I normally allocate brass per barrel, and the amount depends on the chambering.
If you have a couple hundred pieces, I would fire it as virgin with your current load then check after sizing it all, keeping it all at the same firing.
It will likely take a couple hundred rounds for your barrel to break it. It’s common to have a speed up in that time, how much depends on a lot, but in general I don’t consider a load till it has 200 rounds through the barrel.
Once fired compared to virgin should get you better SDs if your sizing consistently, if not you could have better consistency with a quality virgin piece like your seeing. Iv never had a load in a quality chambered barrel go from shooting well to shooting like crap with once fired brass. I have had a barrel speed up significantly in the first few hundred shots, and needed to let off the gas to avoid pressure.
Some food for thought.