What "bewilders" me is why non-residents have this misguided "cult" belief that the Caribou is even remotely a "Trophy" Alaska Big Game Animal.....???
The solution to this "craziness" is for non-residents to "STOP" this silliness. I don't fault the businesses that see an endless supply of silly wabbits, foaming at the mouth, with money in hand willing to pay to shoot the "dumbest" non-trophy animal in Alaska.
You want a solution........stop this "cult" silliness, and invest in the pursuit of a trophy wilderness experience.
I would be very interested to read when and how things shifted, to encourage the hunting of Caribou as a "Trophy". I am stunned that people are incurring the expense and B.S. to go afield and harvest a Caribou.
Note: I am "Not" trolling the members here, I really am "bewildered".
The barren ground caribou is the last great herd/migratory large game animal in North America. That alone makes it a worthy hunt experience unlike almost any other.
Most guys that come up from the lower 48 have access to better deer and elk hunting than they would experience in Alaska. They can even draw moose tags in many Western or Northeastern states. Caribou are an animal that you can only hunt in Alaska, no other state even has any to my knowledge.
I was born in Alaska, we used to hunt moose and caribou at Hatcher Pass and the Denali Highway when I was a boy in the 60s and 70s. I've been up to Alaska to hunt as a non-resident 12-15 times in the past two decades. Several of those hunts were to hunt moose and caribou, several others were to hunt caribou only. I would jump at the chance to have a griz tag and hunt bear, but I can't do that without a guide and I am mostly a meat hunter.
On a remote caribou hunt, a non-res hunter has the potential opportunity to see caribou, moose, grizzly bears, black bears, wolves, wolverines, and maybe even a musk ox in some areas. That alone is worth doing remote caribou hunts in my eyes.
As a longtime guide in Alaska and a resident of the Kenai Peninsula, you've seen many things that non-residents will never have the chance to see. That may affect your perception of caribou somewhat. I will say that I am 60 years old, and I still dream of and look forward to remote AK caribou hunts as much as I did when I was 6 years old and we were heading to the Osar Lake Trail on the Denali for 2 weeks. There's a magic about it that I probably can't express in words.
Hope the fall is good to you and everyone on the Pen -
Michael