This is only to help the op understand. A St Croix, Loomis and ugly stick aren’t in the same league. Not even close but they aren’t marketed at that. The St Croix/Loomis are performance rods, the ugly stick def lacks it. There’s no feel, no sensitivity, too soft. Yes you can be rough with them but so too can you with a rebar or fiberglass driveway rod. Those too also have no feel. If keeping things from breaking is your main objective I’d say ugly stick is prob the way to go. If actually feeling a fish, having a quick responsive rod is your objective than ugly stick couldn’t be a consideration. Way too soft and slow. I guess it’s up to what you’re gonna do with it.
In the situation this poster relayed it might be the right answer for him. I’d just be careful but I guess it’s just the way I handle fishing rods. For me that’s never an issue. I hike with mine as well and through pretty thick cover at times especially as a younger man