Trespassing = $$$ paid to the landowner?

[OsoMountain]

I’ve always thought it a bit stupid that someone could “own” land.

 

[swavescatter]

I’ve always thought it a bit stupid that someone could “own” land.

I had a guy walk into my land, right past two No Trespassing signs and caught him on multiple trail cams. Obvious shed hunter. I posted on Facebook to see if anyone knew him (mostly just so someone that does will share it with him and let him know he's a documented jack@ss)...

I was blown away that half the comments were people like you that seemingly did not agree with the concept of private property when it comes to land. None would offer their home address to invite anyone in though. Eye opening to hear some of the rationale that people use to justify trespassing while hunting (poaching).

 

[OsoMountain]

I had a guy walk into my land, right past two No Trespassing signs and caught him on multiple trail cams. Obvious shed hunter. I posted on Facebook to see if anyone knew him (mostly just so someone that does will share it with him and let him know he's a documented jack@ss)...

I was blown away that half the comments were people like you that seemingly did not agree with the concept of private property when it comes to land. None would offer their home address to invite anyone in though. Eye opening to hear some of the rationale that people use to justify trespassing while hunting (poaching).

I said I thought it was stupid, not that I didn’t abide by it. Monumental difference.

 

[AHayes111]

Whips out the checkbook, and asks "How much is this going to cost to make it go away?"

Had a guy offer me a 100 bill one time. I didn't take the money.

 

[OsoMountain]

Had a guy offer me a 100 bill one time. I didn't take the money.

“How much for your dignity and integrity. Shoot me a number.”

 

[2buffalo]

I’ve always thought it a bit stupid that someone could “own” land.

 

[5MilesBack]

The trespasser whipped out $800, paid the landowner and left with his bull and no criminal charges. Neighboring landowners were pissed at the situation

What were the neighbors pissed about??? That situation didn't involve them at all.

 

[OsoMountain]

What were the neighbors pissed about??? That situation didn't involve them at all.

I agree. Seems to me like the situation resolved itself between the parties involved. Why would anyone else be upset?

 

[OsoMountain]

View attachment 1057140

. You would have received more style points for posting Friedich Engles. Marx is low hanging fruit. Have you ever read of their works? Big ol’ pile of dog shit.

Don’t get it misconstrued, friend. Just because I don’t cheer for your favorite football team, doesn’t mean I’m a fan for their conference rivals. I frankly don’t give a damn about any political ideology. I do not align myself, nor swear any allegiance to any formal government. Why would I?

 

[nodakian]

The ranch ownerr where I used to hunt antelope would snag trespassers and tell them, "you can pay me and go on your way, or you can pay the game warden and lose your license". He always made a few hundred bucks. I had no problem with it for two reasons: 1) it was his land, and he was free to choose how to handle unauthorized entry, and 2) he freed the thinly-spread wardens to handle bigger problems.

The legal system exists to sort things out when people cannot or will not do it themselves. It is not perfect, but it ia better than anarchy and vigilante justice. Since the parties in this case were able to agree on compensation, the legal system could move on to more important issues.

 

[Weldor]

Doesn't the definition of extortion fit this scenario?

Yes.

 

[TheTone]

What were the neighbors pissed about??? That situation didn't involve them at all.

Mainly that a very new to the area landowner took the money instead of prosecuting the guy and having him face actual consequences for his actions

 

[Weldor]

I'm sure the hunters (non-residents ) would rather pay than have to return multiple times for court. Just a thought. And yes trespassing is trespassing any way you slice it. Is trespassing in Idaho a civil infraction or criminal?

 

[dtrkyman]

Trespassing gets you a fine, why shouldn’t it go to the landowner? At least a portion of it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[OsoMountain]

Trespassing is the damage. You are interfering with and damaging my property rights when you enter my property without permission. If you can walk all over my land as long as you don't do any other damage, then you have diminished my right to quiet enjoyment of my property. If I cannot exclude people from my property, then I don't really own it.

In American law, we think of property rights as a "bundle of sticks." The five main sticks are typically identified as:
Possession: The right to occupy the property.
Control: The right to use or alter the property within legal limits.
Exclusion: The right to prevent others from entering or using the property.
Enjoyment: The right to use the property in any legal manner.
Disposition: The right to sell, will, or transfer ownership.

You never owned it to begin with. Now be a good boy and pay your property taxes so Uncle Sam doesn’t take it away from you.

 

[Q_Sertorius]

You never owned it to begin with. Now be a good boy and pay your property taxes so Uncle Sam doesn’t take it away from you.

There’s no federal property tax. Only a state one.

All ownership is predicated on having force to defend your rights. In this case, we, as a society, have decided that having the state enforce those rights beats having to defend them against all comers. I’ve been to enough places without the rule of law, thank you very much. Respect for property rights is a fundamental basis for a free society.

 

[OsoMountain]

There’s no federal property tax. Only a state one.

All ownership is predicated on having force to defend your rights. In this case, we, as a society, have decided that having the state enforce those rights beats having to defend them against all comers. I’ve been to enough places without the rule of law, thank you very much. Respect for property rights is a fundamental basis for a free society.

Funny, I never mentioned what level of government?

Maybe it’s my general hatred for this dog shit society?

 

[Q_Sertorius]

Funny, I never mentioned what level of government?

Maybe it’s my general hatred for this dog shit society?

 

[OsoMountain]

Of course! Why didn’t I think of leaving?!