Depends on the person and use. Is someone saying your Tikka is a POS and won’t work now?
Nope never said that was genuinely curious your thoughts on how much “better” the pic rail will truly make it? Stronger, more robust? I like the ease of pic rails and the variety of rings available so that is what would make it better for me…
I don’t think you and others understand at all. It is not between a “tikka and this new action”. It’s between “an R700 ‘custom’ and all the inherent compromises that entails, versus this new action”.
From what I gathered via the podcast is this is going to take tikka parts and vise versa, what makes this action new aside it says UM and not tikka?
Yes. Can you show me where I stated that I would choose to do it for my use, or most users? That it doesn’t make the rifle more reliable, doesn’t change the reality that people want 5lb rifles. Wilson choose a 5lb R700 based gun, or a 5lb Tikka based gun….
I will try to be more clear on this, never did I say you would choose it at least when I typed it and read it again just now I didn’t say that. I don’t think it changed magically on your screen but I could be wrong. I’m sure it won’t be hard to read back through and see where you have said every time something is done to the action outside of nitride I believe was some sort of compromise. If that is the case what will make this a better action aside from being lighter. The second part of that question is what will change with this action over the lightening cuts, sheep port, etc that is done to a factory action.
That’s exactly what you would have- which is exactly what some people want.
No kidding so how does it have a tikka foot print, use tikka bolts, and tikka accessories and not compromise what makes the tikka great. Again what does this action accomplish that you can’t get with the UM mods already offered. Same quality action at a lower price, Ti or Aluminum action?
You mean like the 87 different companies that make R700 “custom” actions? Isn’t “so common” and “made by everyone” used as plus for the R700 pattern? But for a Tikka based design that is wrong?
Yes exactly, I have limited experience with all of these customs no doubt. Aside from some machining advancements or quality, integral rail, recoil lug design in my eyes they are all the same. The only reason I’m paying for a custom rem clone over a 700 action is for tighter tolerances allowing for Prefits, better extractor (maybe?), and integral rail. The tikka already had this stuff covered realistically. Would a pic rail be a better option than the dovetail, sure but it’s not a deal breaker.
Wrong? Not at all, but it needs to be different, from what it was described it doesn’t sound all that different. A pic rail, nitride, and some lightening cuts doesn’t seem that revolutionary to me, certainly not worth the expense for the gain unless they plan to keep the price in line with what it costs to work over an existing tikka.
You believe they are going to have an action, and not make bolts?
Where did you pull this idea from? I said make bolts it’s what we need, the demand for bolts to swap calibers in existing actions seems to be there. I would expect it would do well for them given the cost and difficulty of getting tikka factory bolts. I was in no way talking about their new fancy action. Skip the custom action and make bolts for tikka actions, make sense?
With all due respect the questions I asked were genuine inquires not an argument. I’m trying to figure out how this new action will be so great vs what is already available. Unless it’s a totally new redesign I don’t see where it won’t be a compromise in some way, price, quality, availability, reliability, etc. Something has to change.
I can understand they are trying to accomplish what the custom 700s are doing, using tikkas footprint, bolt, trigger, and barrel dimensions and calling it a custom. Will it be worth the cost over a factory tikka I guess we won’t know until it’s here. I personally never will know, I’m happy enough with my factory actions and barrels, what I would like to see is a good magazine like the Waters available in the US. I can see the argument for this custom action over a custom 700 I guess. If that is what we are comparing to carry on.