The 18l is like a hip pack on a set of pack straps. I already have a 28 as well, but its a different animal. You might not like the 18 either, of course. Id have to try but I think your stick carrying would be a no-go for me, so we clearly have a different perspective on this, but imo it objectively works extremely well and addresses at least some of your gripes. Imo that 18 is unlike anything else Ive ever seen because it sits so low on your back—the top of the pack bag is around the middle of your back, so ducking and weaving through brush its like you arent wearing a pack at all b/c there is literally nothing there to catch on anything.
View attachment 958946