IME spray foam/great stuff/ blueboard stops arrows just fine, but the problem I experienced is the friction created by the arrow entering the target would actually melt a bit of foam to the shaft and over time (not much time) there was a buildup of hard plastic melted foam coating the front half of the arrow. I bagged that idea and moved to carpet which has worked awesome.
  
	 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
					
				 
						
					 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		 
 
		