I really like my Fanatic beanie, but don't wear it often. We have the blaze orange (rifle season) requirement for most of cold weather months. It does a great job. Very warm. Stops wind well. If any activity this thing can get too warm. I would recommend it.
For colder weather when the blaze orange requirement is in effect, I will wear the Sitka Ballistic. Not as warm, but I normally wear a UA Coldgear Infrared balaclava under the beanie. That balaclava offers protection on the neck without bulk. This worked well this past "fall" on 1st rifle season elk hunt when we had couple mornings below 15F. Only issue I have with the Ballistic is that is one size fits all and can be snug on the larger head.
Next year I am considering trying the Kuiu Kenai Bomber cap. Might look like Elmer Fudd, but it comes in blaze orange.