Sitka Ascent 12 vs. Eberlestock Bandit

[Aroostook]

Hello Backpack Aficionados,

We are in a boreal forest ecosystem and are looking for a day pack that can handle wet/winter hunting. We are constantly entangled in cedar swamp labyrinths, getting torn up in old clear cuts and most importantly moving swiftly and quietly. Prices being equal; out of the Sitka Ascent 12 and Eberlestock Bandit what bag do you think would best fit our needs?

Thanks,
Aroostook