I purchased the Silvertip for this past seasons September Elk hunt out in Idaho, on return I was seriously contemplating of throwing it up for sale, but after some reflection I am absolutely keeping it.
Pros:
Very Mobile and Easy to Pitch
Easy to pitch, small enough foot print where its wasn't impossible to find a good piece of level ground that wasn't in a ditch. This was extremely important to me as I was hunting off my back and camp was were I ended up that night. The Silvertip is a breeze to pitch, stake out the four corners, stick the center pole, tighten up the rest of the stake outs.....DONE. There were a couple of nights were I was struggling to find a good location to set up because it was either to steep or not in a high spot which really bugged me out, since this was the first time I was running a floorless and was worried about getting wet since we had rain for a couple of the days out. There were points in the trip where I was thinking the Cimmaron would of been the better choice because of the size and space, but thinking back when it came to finding a location every night in some random draws I was glad I didn't, this is one of the reasons I decided to keep the tent.
Bomb Proof in the Wind/Rain/Snow
Had a couple of nights where it was blowing 30 mph hard to the point I was getting a little worried, this little tent ate it up.
Cons:
Condensation
I was able to fix this issue, so not really sure its a con, but worth mentioning. First night pitched the tent to tight to the ground, it snowed over night and the condensation just plain sucked. The next morning I threw some guy lines onto the stake outs and pitched the tent to where the sod skirt was just touching the ground. This provided some additional ventilation and pretty much managed the condensation going forward.
I wish Seek outside would install the same ventilation system it does on there bigger tents, the current system in the top of the shelter kind of sucks. I through a stick in to keep it open but later pulled it out since it looked like it was going to rip it.
This shelter is a step above minimalist, to me its a single person tent. There were a couple of days where I had to hunker down due to the rain. I thought if I had another dude in here with me the condensation would suck and it would be tight, no way could we pack in our gear and not feel totally claustrophobic. Being confined to the tent for hours at a time, I tried to picture how the space would look like with a stove, I don't think it would be to bad, the only concern I had was rolling into it during the night, might not be a factor just a thought. During this time I thought of selling the shelter and going to a Cimmaron, just for the extra head room to be able to sit up in, but in the end of the day I spend most of this time catching up on sleep.
The Silvertip is what it is, if your looking for a shelter that can sleep 2 + Gear+Stove and can stand up in, then its not for you. If you're looking for a solo shelter to crawl into and not worry about it getting blown away then its one to consider. I will be sending it back this spring to get the stove jack installed, will be considering a stove for this season. I think having a stove when the weather sucks and having the ability dry out and warm up would have been a mental game changer.