I have seen that thread and for sure Formidolosus knows better than most people here so if you plan to use a gun intensively (like at a shooting class) degreasing is a good idea, especially if you don’t care much about very long term conservation of the rifle. Unless the manufacturer suggests against it, which sometimes happens. If i had to do an international competition or go to war with the rifle, i would degrease. That said, i want my hunting RIfles to last a lot of time and to me is very important that nothing rusts and i know i can check torque regularly, especially after shooting many rounds.
especially with my collectibles i would never degrease every screw and screw hole. I think wiping the screws down with a clean cotton patch is a good compromise in this case.
I think it is a matter of usa of the rifle.
I will always follow what manufactorers say on this specific technical aspects because materials and torque values are different and only they know if the specs are for dry or “not chemically cleaned” threads. Also torquing without any trace of oil can be less reliable of the two dry surfaces have some inconsistent contact and the torque wrench snaps too early because of it.
That said, i think that this subject is vastly overthinked on. if the rifle keeping zero was so dependent on drying everything up with degreasers, there wouldn’t be contrasting opinions in the shooter community and among manufacturers. It would be clear what is the right thing to do..
Most people will never have a rifle lose zero with normal use even if they don’t degrease, as long as they torque everything more or less to specs. I am pretty sure about this