I've used an ll bean commando crewneck sweater for the past year. Really love it, very easy to make super warm with some baselayers.Yeah I love them, I run hot and it’s been working well this winter. I do plan to try the Ranger as well…
I got a ranger sweater a month ago, and my first impression was I paid $318 for a sweater that doesn't itch, but functionally wasn't any better than the $89 commando.
Now I love the ranger. Warmer and better at cutting wind than the ll bean, but still has at least the same upper comfort level.
I know the Maine is supposed to be lighter and less itchy than the commando though.