Can't comment on Idaho's but I have tried a pair of Wyomings. Ordered both those and the Nevadas to try since I have no local retailers. The Nevada fit my foot like a glove, but the Wyoming wasn't quite as nice of a fit for me. I think the Idaho would be a serviceable boot for sure, but if you get the chance to order a couple pairs with the intention of returning one or two, or trying some on in person somewhere you'll likely be money ahead. Ran the Nevadas here in the midwest this past fall and loved them. Will also use them on a elk hunt this fall.