I went to a saddle for 90% of deer hunting on public. I have a latitude 2-panel saddle and their carbon sticks with a sub 3lb platform. The entire setup is around 12lbs. A lot of times I am carrying the sticks and platform bundled in one hand and my bow in the other or on my shoulders. Everything else is organized in order of use in two pouches on the saddle (left side and right side). It is an insanely mobile setup compared to hiking in with my lone wolf on my back. At the end of the first season I was four sticks up with bow hung sitting still hunting in about 20 minutes from the base of the tree. Same for getting out. Hunting to walking out in about 20 min. That is going "slow" and being very careful and always attached to the tree.
There are some cons that took some getting used to for me, off the top of head:
- weak side shots require more movement, so practice and be prepared.
- getting busted from movement with deer from behind. You can see 360 degrees from saddle, but generally you are not looking behind you. In a stand you are blocked by the tree, but you can't shoot there anyway so it feels like a con for saddle, but in reality you actually have more opportunities.
- fidget factor. There is so much ability to adjust for comfort that I often find myself adjusting things after several hours. You'll get it figured out after some time in the saddle. It can be too easy to move around a lot in the beginning.
- being skylined, be conscious of sun direction
- adding / removing layers can be a pain, especially when hiking in when temps are below freezing and down to single digits. Again takes some practice figuring out a system that works for you. I hunted several days this season with wind chills below zero just fine. But you must have a system with some practice.
- Bino harness / hand muff and bridge all kind of in the same place. Not sure what everyone is doing for this. Most times I don't use a Bino harness, but I did change to a lower profile FHF gear from Alaska Guide Creations for the saddle.
- putting on boot blankets or artic shield once you are up is doable, but takes a little practice.