Riley stoves vs Four dog stoves

[Bubblehide]

Well, after going with the Riley over the Four Dog a year ago, I'm back on the market for a stove. Just came back from a trip with the Riley and it smoked us out of the tent a few times. I always wondered why there were small holes at the seam along the top of the stove, as well as gaps around the door, but it had not been an issue in the first few burns I did with it.

This time, however, it failed us big time, and we had to end up sleeping with no heat in 14 deg. lows. due to the smoke it was puffing out continuously in the tent.

Judging from the Four Dog website, it looks like maybe Don is not making the titaniums right now? Does anybody have any recommendations for a stove in similar weight categories as these? Preferably with a good seal.

I've have a few Riely stoves and have used them for a few decades. What you describe can only be user error (no offense intended). Something had to be blocking the airflow out of the stove. It happened to me once in all the time I've used Riley stoves, and it was a broken dampner in the stove pipe, looking like it was open, but it was nonfunctional and closed inside the stove pipe. It was a simple fix of just removing it and not having a stove pipe damper for that trip.

I've never used a Four Dog stove, so I can't comment on them or compare efficiency.

 

[Pelagic]

I got one from A metal works, he is making the old 4 dog stoves.

A Metal Werks

ametalwerks.com

Interesting. Thanks for sharing the site. Looks like he doesn’t have the titanium stoves listed though. Only the steel. Any idea if he is doing those as well as the steel?

 

[cmahoney]

No he just makes the steel ones


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Pelagic]

What you describe can only be user error (no offense intended). Something had to be blocking the airflow out of the stove.

I assumed user error as well, and haven’t completely ruled it out. But assuming it was something I was doing, I double checked the chimney cap and spark arrestor at the top of the stack, as well as made sure the damper was lined up right to be open, confirming this after I took the chimney apart. The only other thing I can think of was that the creosote was a little thicker than typical, but certainly nowhere near thick enough to block any airflow.

 

[Bubblehide]

I assumed user error as well, and haven’t completely ruled it out. But assuming it was something I was doing, I double checked the chimney cap and spark arrestor at the top of the stack, as well as made sure the damper was lined up right to be open, confirming this after I took the chimney apart. The only other thing I can think of was that the creosote was a little thicker than typical, but certainly nowhere near thick enough to block any airflow.

That sounds odd. You can get smoked out from closing the damper on the stove, as it is then unable to draw air and exhaust the smoke out the pipe; or a blockage in the stove pipe trapping the smoke in the stove, to leak out as it can, based on design. I put metal mesh on my chimney top and carry a stainless brush to clean it periodically. However, if the damper in the chimney pipe is broken, it can appear to be lined up properly and venting, when it is physically in the closed position inside the pipe. The only way to truelt know iui s to remove that section of pipe (when it's cool enough) and visually inspect it. I go a step further and remove the dampner to inspect it. Over time thay can rust, heat stress or a combination of the 2 and become dysfunctional. Some guys use a bowl shaped piece of metal mesh inside the pipe than can become clogged. It is important to periodically inspect and clean then, as often as daily depending on wood quality and volume burnt.