I have one of these, it works great. I haven't had another one to compare it to though. It is really light for how big the blade is.Not really "elk specific", but I consider my Bahco Laplander saw a must-have.
Inexpensive (around 20 bucks), lightweight, and works fantastic on anything and everything I've tried to cut.
I do the same, but my concern was the extra weight of the skull, I'll be limited on how much weight I can pack considering how far I'll be in, and how rough the trail coming out is. One of our spike camps may be in around 15 miles, so if we tag out two elk, that's a lot of heavy trips back and forth for 30 plus miles. I may be walking out, and leading a couple horses if worse comes to worse. Thanks for the helpI normally use the gutless method to take the elk apart, so have no need to split the brisket. Then I can use a knife only to debone the meat, so no saw needed. I can still take the legs apart at the joint with a knife if I choose to leave the bone in. If I decide that I need the saw to remove the antlers from the scull, I can pack it back in on the second trip after I've unloaded all the nonessential items for the pack out. I use a Wyoming saw when I do carry a saw in.