PALISADES, ID BLACK BEAR

[amateurhourhunter]

Taking a trip to Idaho in October just NW of Palisades Reservoir. Anyone ever hunted this area for black bear? Just trying to get a feel on the population of cinnamons and the size of them. Thank you

 

[elkguide]

Welcome to the forum.

 

[amateurhourhunter]

Thank you. Use rockslide for reviews but never thought to join.

 

[PathFinder]

Since you're plainly new, we can afford to be nice just once.
Don't ask about where to find animals in specific areas. Here's why:
1. It's the best way to paint yourself as entirely incompetent; nobody will want to interact with you
2. If anyone says anything, they're either lying or also incompetent
3. Blowing up spots on the internet ruins western hunting.

If you want to be successful, go earn it. Nobody is giving you anything for free. And if you are successful, keep it as a secret to yourself. Don't come back and go handing out free information on the web.

 

[amateurhourhunter]

Since you're plainly new, we can afford to be nice just once.
Don't ask about where to find animals in specific areas. Here's why:
1. It's the best way to paint yourself as entirely incompetent; nobody will want to interact with you
2. If anyone says anything, they're either lying or also incompetent
3. Blowing up spots on the internet ruins western hunting.

If you want to be successful, go earn it. Nobody is giving you anything for free. And if you are successful, keep it as a secret to yourself. Don't come back and go handing out free information on the web.

Not one time did I ask for specifics. Very general question. Good day to you.

 

[bbassi]

Since you're plainly new, we can afford to be nice just once.
Don't ask about where to find animals in specific areas. Here's why:
1. It's the best way to paint yourself as entirely incompetent; nobody will want to interact with you
2. If anyone says anything, they're either lying or also incompetent
3. Blowing up spots on the internet ruins western hunting.

If you want to be successful, go earn it. Nobody is giving you anything for free. And if you are successful, keep it as a secret to yourself. Don't come back and go handing out free information on the web.

If you call that nice I'd hate to see what you call being a prick.

 

[unclericco]

I’ll second that. No one wants to read shitty posts like this, especially to a new guy on the forum.

 

[amateurhourhunter]

I’ll second that. No one wants to read shitty posts like this, especially to a new guy on the forum.

I thought I just asked a general question, did not mention a gmu, didn’t ask for specific areas or anyones honey hole. I read the rules. Really if someone said yea cinnamons are there I would have been grateful for that.

 

[PredatorSlayer]

I thought I just asked a general question, did not mention a gmu, didn’t ask for specific areas or anyones honey hole. I read the rules. Really if someone said yea cinnamons are there I would have been grateful for that.

I hunt out that way all the time. You did ask about a very specific area. Why would anyone tell you cinnamons or any bears or game are there? I say go kick rocks and figure it out yourself

 

[amateurhourhunter]

I hunt out that way all the time. You did ask about a very specific area. Why would anyone tell you cinnamons or any bears or game are there? I say go kick rocks and figure it out yourself

“Just NW” ain’t that specific. Yea why would hunters help other hunters on a hunting forum.

 

[PredatorSlayer]

“Just NW” ain’t that specific. Yea why would hunters help other hunters on a hunting forum.

Just NW of palisades reservoir is very specific, more specific than a GMU. You want general advice on bear hunting that isn’t area specific? Sure. You want numbers and colors on a specific area? Nah…go figure it out yourself

 

[mtnwrunner]

I just don't understand why it is so hard to be civil.

Randy