@Brigham @ Outdoor Vitals Welcome to Rokslide! Saw that you joined and figured it would be best to get your first hand review on the quilt mentioned in the subject.
Any recommended sleeping pads for this specific quilt?
Go ahead and sell me on it!
Haha, well I'm no good at sales and about as far from a marketer as one can get!
I'll start with the second question. Easiest question first. My go-to answer is Thermarest NeoAir Xtherm NXT. It has the best warmth to weight ratio there is. It is lighter than most pads with R-values 2 lower than itself. It is also the most durable in terms of fabric in the backpacking category. It has a 70d nylon on the bottom, which no one else really has. That is a very important consideration. I want the pad with the least likelihood of puncturing on a hunt. This is the one. I think it's adequately comfortable, but not any better than 'good.' There is enough thickness that I can deflate it a little bit and not contact the ground. If I could only have one pad, this it it.
I have used others, like Nemo Tensor Ultralight. It was a little more comfortable than the Xtherm, but a little heavier, and it punctured more than once. Done with that one.
The previous generation Big Agnes Rapide SL is a good pad. I think it's well balanced for comfort, R-value, and durability. I have many nights on that one and no punctures yet. It's a little more comfortable than the Tensor and Xtherm. Also a little thicker and I like the baffle orientation. This pad has since been updated and I have not used the updated version so I can't speak on it.
I have limited experience with the Thermarest NeoAir Neoloft. Its very new. Massively thick, and the standard version is 2 inches wider than most 'standard.' It is definitely the plushest, most comfortable pad I've used. But I only have a few nights on it so I can't speak to durability yet. It is obviously heavier. Like 1.5 lbs plus or minus. But I would consider taking it on certain hunts or backpacking trips, where I know I could maintain a very light pack, and therefore justify the extra weight of that one item.
I need to say that with quilts, a pad with an adequate R-value is paramount. Err on the side of warmer, not what you can just get by with.
Contd....