I have an older version of the Kenai jacket and bought the new Kenai pants when they came out last summer. I enjoy my kenai jacket down to about 20F, and the pants were marketed to be warmer than previous kenai.I was hoping for a garment that had at or near the amount of warmth that my Grumman down jacket provides on my top half. The Grumman for me provides INSTANT, game-changing warmth in frigid temperatures. This was the level of warmth I was looking for.
Truth be told they have served their purpose ok, however I am pretty disappointed with the face fabric, and they didn’t perform to the level warmth-wise that I dreamed of when buying them.
These are my first puffy pants. They are not anywhere near as lofty as my older kenai jacket (which I love) and though they claim superior warmth to previous iterations, I don’t think these lived up to that hype. The face fabric is already super pilled up, after only one season of use. And although I have not yet managed to tear it or get any abrasions, it is not near as tough as they make it sound.
Bottom line: Did they perform better than not having a puffy pant, yes, and they are relatively warm when paired with all my other layers. Were they key on a North slope caribou trip this year, yes, it was mid 30s-50s and wet, this is probably a niche condition where I will continue to use them. Were they key on my late season Idaho mule deer hunt, yes, temps were frigid and below 0F at times, 15-25F for most of the time, although I was happy to have something, I think there is a warmer garment out there that would have served the purpose better. They are quiet, and they wick moisture quite well. However, I still carry my zip off long johns. I am also still doing quite a few pushups on the glassing knob to kick the furnace on and stay comfortable when it’s below 20 degrees. They look more like they have 3-4 seasons of use than the 1 season of use that they received.
I am still looking for a piece that fills niche of wicked, warm with a wicked warmth to weight ratio.
Any folks out there that have used these and the lost park pants, super down ultra, super down pro, or Grumman, and able to break down a direct comparison?