Why?CELOX packets x3 (I honestly think a quickclot combat gauze would be a better replacemnt for both the celox and the s-gauze)
I admittedly don’t know a ton about the reaction differences in the two, and perhaps a celox impregnated gauze would be best of all options. I think that the seperate celox powder and a rolled gauze pad has a bit more “fiddle” factor which could make it harder or less effective to apply. I worry about being able to get the powdered celox deep into a wound if needed vs being able to pack in an already impregnated gauze.Why?
QuickClot is a mineral based agent that only activates a functional clotting cascade.
Celox is a chitin based product that will form a clot without a functional clotting cascade.
There are other reasons I prefer chitin based products, but the above hits on the most important.
This. 100%. However if I loose an airway or get a pneumo I just assume I am as good as dead unless help can arrive quickly anyway.Light on first aid specific gear, heavy on knowledge.
Most first aid kits are really comfort kits.
The key questions are:
1. Do you know when to extract and have a method of communicating?
2. Can you treat and prevent hypothermia? My shelter and sleep system are part of my first aid kit.
3. Can you manage heat injury?
4. Can you manage dehydration?
5. Do you have a good chance of stopping major bleeding that can be stopped in the field?
6. Can you manage an airway?
7. Can you manage chest trauma and tension pathology?
There are many ways to do most of those things. Some require more knowledge than others. Most can be achieved without dedicated gear, but will be easier with equipment designed for the task.
Edit:
8. Can you reasonably stabilize a fracture to minimize further damage?
Yes on impregnated gauze. I dislike the idea of fiddling with power.I admittedly don’t know a ton about the reaction differences in the two, and perhaps a celox impregnated gauze would be best of all options. I think that the seperate celox powder and a rolled gauze pad has a bit more “fiddle” factor which could make it harder or less effective to apply. I worry about being able to get the powdered celox deep into a wound if needed vs being able to pack in an already impregnated gauze.
This sort of highlights how environment-based it is.My first aid kit has grown considerably over the last few years. I've had some very close calls with potentially significant injuries in the deep backcountry. I also do a lot of backcountry skiing which carries a significant risk for injury and I am familiar with some fatalities in the same areas that I have skied where key items such as Nasopharygeal Airway, tourniquets, chest seals etc would have potentially changed the outcome. Lot of different schools of thought, but I am increasingly less impressed with cavalier attitudes.