Like all boots, what really matters is how they fit YOUR foot. I have these boots, and in fact, they are my first and only pair of "premium" hunting boots. I used the Lathrop & Sons custom fit system deal and these boots were what they recommended for me. I have found that with the Lowa boots' lacing system I have been able to really lock in the heal and not even using any super complicated lacing strategies. I have a wide forefoot and the ability to leave the forefoot of the boot a little loose and then lock in the midfoot is very nice. (I would assume many manufacturers have this ability, but I haven't had much experience) I did have trouble with these boots over supinating my feet which initially caused a fair amount of pain on my 5th metatarsal head (sole of the foot at the base of the small toe). It was actually almost unbearable and my feet would kill after I took the boots off and walked on a hardwood floor barefoot. I was using L&S's special inserts, but they just didn't do it for me. I ended up having custom insoles made by a local orthotist and it completely corrected the problem. I have been using them all fall without a hitch. Granted, I have not been hauling heavy packs in the mountains with them, so this may not be a valid review at all. But I have hiked 15 mile all day upland hunts, hiked through creeks and streams without leakage issues, and sat comfortably in treestands for 10 hour+ clips. I'd keep wearing them indoors as much as you can without too much wear and tear and see how they feel. Try different insoles and/or sock thicknesses. Leukotape if you need. I realize this probably wasn't much help, but just thought I'd share my experience.
Best of luck,
Ryan