I would have to say they were top notch. I know the review you speak of and I think there’s a few of those out there for most outfitters if you look hard enough. I wouldn’t judge on one experience. Their area is awesome, guides are really good and they’ve all been there with Craig awhile (my guide was in his 10th year). My hunt was really tough but they let me stay until I got an opportunity. Killed on the 17th day. I wouldn’t hesitate to book with them again. I also saw lots of moose and elk. One guy killed a 340ish bull the day I got back to the lodge.