Judging moose tips

[TheCougar]

These are both less than 50 inches. A young bull and an old timer past his prime
Both legal in 3 brow tine unit.
View attachment 388603
View attachment 388604

How is that first one less than 50 inches???

Even if I grossly exaggerate the distance between the bases, I can’t make that less than 50 inches. It measures closer to 60” when I use the proper distance for the angler bases. I’m guessing that rifle is 46-48”long, which also puts the rack into the 50s.

 

[cowdisciple]

Tis the season for this thread!

 

[TheCougar]

Might be a bit off… the perspective I think is causing some judging issues - almost like a fisheye effect. The measurements say 60”, but I think it might be less than that.

Tis the season for this thread!

 

[Catag94]

Tis the season for this thread!

Estimated at 54"

Do tell.

 

[cowdisciple]

Estimated at 54"

Do tell.

We measured 55". This was an any bull hunt though, so didn't have to worry about guessing beforehand.

 

[AK_Skeeter]

How is that first one less than 50 inches???

Even if I grossly exaggerate the distance between the bases, I can’t make that less than 50 inches. It measures closer to 60” when I use the proper distance for the angler bases. I’m guessing that rifle is 46-48”long, which also puts the rack into the 50s.

View attachment 922966

View attachment 922967

The first one was 48 inches measured with a tape the morning I shot him.
3 browe tines, so a legal bull. I shot him at 20 yards as he responded to cow calling.

 

[Voyageur]

He barely beat 51" wide. I was pretty surprised when I measured, but am really glad he had the brow tines to be legal either way. We passed on a couple of smaller bulls in the trip, and I'm super glad we did! I don't think I would have shot this guy without the brow tines.

If you notice in the second picture, his tines come forward instead of laying out to the side.

Each year I come back to this thread for some judging practice and each year your bull trips me up. It's always a good reminder (for me) to use Vern's mantra of "think 60" if the brow tines aren't there.

 

[Voyageur]

If anyone has new pictures to add they would be appreciated!

 

[cgoodwin48]

Just wanted to add some input as i often use photos and attempted measurements to gauge Moose. Using pictures of the dead ones is a bit tricky because you often wont get the angle you need for the true perpendicular measurement (as needed for Alaska). The outside edge of the eyes are also usually a better reference point than antler bases in my experience. I built a program on my laptop using the old app (Moose Gauge) for a reference tool but there's still discrepancies and it isn't a truly reliable method for judging.