Is poaching truly this prevalent?

Joined
Apr 17, 2022
Messages
610
Location
SW Idaho
Far too often, casually striking up a hunting conversation with aquaintences, strangers, guys at the range, or friends of friends will lead to some sort of poaching admission. In just the last year, I've had this happen all too often. Below are just a few examples off the top of my head:

-Guy at a holiday party showing off pictures of some elk and mule deer he took that season. He shows me a great buck he killed, tells the story of scouting it but struggling to find it after season opened. With a smile he says, "Well, I do cheat a little..." He then tells me how he uses a thermal monocular to spot large heat signatures to "find the big ones" and was able to relocate and kill the buck.

-A corporate guy at work who told me he hunts several different trophy mule deer units across the state by having his ex-wife, girlfriend, both children, and brother all apply (none of whom hunt). When any of these people draw a tag, he hunts and uses their tag and pre-signed proxy statement.

-A friend of the above corporate guy who freely admits to baiting bear illegally... Close to roads, wrong time of year, using prohibited substances, and has at least one unpermitted bait location. A few years ago this guy also made FB posts about him and another guy each killing cow elk in a certain unit, but offline admitted he shot both cows himself in a completely different unit, hundreds of miles away (a different coworker actually reported this and the bear baits to IDFG, nothing has come of it thus far).

-A guy I hunted with a few years back told me he usually kills cow elk during muzzleloader season with a rifle because "it's easier, and you can just say you're wolf hunting if anyone asks." Needless to say I do not hunt with this guy anymore. He also once filled his one and only deer tag, then shot another buck later that season and attached a bear tag to it. He actually got checked at a checkstation on the way home, portrayed it like some big mistake and made it out of there with some sort of a verbal warning and his (second, illegal) buck.

-Brother of the above guy told me he killed a 180" MD buck in a draw-only trophy unit, with an OTC tag for a neighboring unit. He said it was fine because he was "still pretty close to the unit the tag was for."

-this past season, after getting skunked on the draw, I hunted on a general OTC bull tag in a very busy unit with lots of roads (most of which close specifically for this elk season). There were side-by-sides EVERYWHERE, going completely off-trail and tearing up closed roads. More than once my hunting partner and I had hunts blown by people taking 4-wheelers and SxS past us on a closed road. We ran into a guy hunting with his kids, who said he likes bringing the kids because he's "pretty sure that youth can shoot either sex." Spoiler alert, that's not true.

-lots of party-hunting/herd shooting/"oops we shot too many" stories, not to mention the rodeos and making unethical shots at distances outside of hunter capabilities... all stories told with a laugh and excitement to do it again next year.


Is this new? Has it always been this way? I'm ignorant to the "good old days." I am a long time shooter but admittedly a late-ish onset hunter. What I lack in experience I make up for in passion for the wildlife, a love for the outdoors and the hunting experience, care for conservation, and a thirst for knowledge and skills (I always try to contribute to this forum and ask questions humbly and honestly). I hunt the West, and sometimes am lucky enough to take 1, or God willing, maybe 2 game animals a year. I'm not a rich guy. Hunting is not cheap for me. I make financial and social sacrifices to make it happen. To hear guys bragging about taking more than they should just floors me.


TL;DR

Is poaching gradually becoming more prevalent? Has it always been prevalent? Do people just feel more emboldened to share their poaching than they used to?

Thanks for the space to vent.
 
Maybe you give off a vibe that makes others think you will be receptive to stories of poaching?
Ive had a few folks tell stories of party hunting, but I think those folks think it’s ok in their minds.

But yes, I think poaching is very common. You have to figure they only catch maybe 10% of poachers.
 
Yes, instances like this are prevalent

Thermals are unfortunately legal to use for spotting game in Idaho(or at least were, I didn’t keep up with what happened in the legislature)

Lots of guys are hunting on their wives’ tags or grandmas tags, I had several people ask me why I didn’t shoot a 185” buck this year in a unit my son had a tag for, my only answer was “ethics”

Also plenty of people who don’t know or honestly don’t care about unit boundaries.

The sad reality is until we have more game wardens in the field and poaching convictions start to come with some teeth people will always continue to cheat


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Far too often, casually striking up a hunting conversation with aquaintences, strangers, guys at the range, or friends of friends will lead to some sort of poaching admission. In just the last year, I've had this happen all too often. Below are just a few examples off the top of my head:

-Guy at a holiday party showing off pictures of some elk and mule deer he took that season. He shows me a great buck he killed, tells the story of scouting it but struggling to find it after season opened. With a smile he says, "Well, I do cheat a little..." He then tells me how he uses a thermal monocular to spot large heat signatures to "find the big ones" and was able to relocate and kill the buck.

-A corporate guy at work who told me he hunts several different trophy mule deer units across the state by having his ex-wife, girlfriend, both children, and brother all apply (none of whom hunt). When any of these people draw a tag, he hunts and uses their tag and pre-signed proxy statement.

-A friend of the above corporate guy who freely admits to baiting bear illegally... Close to roads, wrong time of year, using prohibited substances, and has at least one unpermitted bait location. A few years ago this guy also made FB posts about him and another guy each killing cow elk in a certain unit, but offline admitted he shot both cows himself in a completely different unit, hundreds of miles away (a different coworker actually reported this and the bear baits to IDFG, nothing has come of it thus far).

-A guy I hunted with a few years back told me he usually kills cow elk during muzzleloader season with a rifle because "it's easier, and you can just say you're wolf hunting if anyone asks." Needless to say I do not hunt with this guy anymore. He also once filled his one and only deer tag, then shot another buck later that season and attached a bear tag to it. He actually got checked at a checkstation on the way home, portrayed it like some big mistake and made it out of there with some sort of a verbal warning and his (second, illegal) buck.

-Brother of the above guy told me he killed a 180" MD buck in a draw-only trophy unit, with an OTC tag for a neighboring unit. He said it was fine because he was "still pretty close to the unit the tag was for."

-this past season, after getting skunked on the draw, I hunted on a general OTC bull tag in a very busy unit with lots of roads (most of which close specifically for this elk season). There were side-by-sides EVERYWHERE, going completely off-trail and tearing up closed roads. More than once my hunting partner and I had hunts blown by people taking 4-wheelers and SxS past us on a closed road. We ran into a guy hunting with his kids, who said he likes bringing the kids because he's "pretty sure that youth can shoot either sex." Spoiler alert, that's not true.

-lots of party-hunting/herd shooting/"oops we shot too many" stories, not to mention the rodeos and making unethical shots at distances outside of hunter capabilities... all stories told with a laugh and excitement to do it again next year.


Is this new? Has it always been this way? I'm ignorant to the "good old days." I am a long time shooter but admittedly a late-ish onset hunter. What I lack in experience I make up for in passion for the wildlife, a love for the outdoors and the hunting experience, care for conservation, and a thirst for knowledge and skills (I always try to contribute to this forum and ask questions humbly and honestly). I hunt the West, and sometimes am lucky enough to take 1, or God willing, maybe 2 game animals a year. I'm not a rich guy. Hunting is not cheap for me. I make financial and social sacrifices to make it happen. To hear guys bragging about taking more than they should just floors me.


TL;DR

Is poaching gradually becoming more prevalent? Has it always been prevalent? Do people just feel more emboldened to share their poaching than they used to?

Thanks for the space to vent.
Some states like Oregon will give you points depending on the offense for turning in poachers. Looking for that elk hunt that you can’t catch up to in points?
 
Wait till you see 80 percent of the hunters in Hawaii. Everyone trespasses, and go outlaw. Spotlight/nods with air rifles at night on the roads then throw them in the truck real quick. Sneaking on to golf courses at night. Cutting locks and gates then putting their own lock on state/government land you’re not allowed to hunt on to begin with lol. List goes on and on. Dlnr does absolutely nothing except for minor fines which are probably used to offset the cost of monthly aerial shooting and high fencing the few units we are allowed to actually hunt
 
I can't speak to whether it has always been this way. But my experience (New Mexico, Utah, Arizona) mirrors yours (Idaho?). So, I'm guessing it's pretty much how it is nowadays at least.
 
I think it's it's kinda like drinking and driving... Some people get away with it for years... Possibly hundreds of times before being caught for a "first offense"...
This comparison is ignorant! The outcome of driving intoxicated can kill innocent people.

The getting away with it is one thing, but to tie it with drinking and driving just doesn’t sit right with me.
 
Poaching is very common. I worked at a local mom and pop gun store for years. I would venture a guess that 50% of the hunters I interacted with were poachers.

Most common things I would see would be guys who would tag bucks as antlerless deer, so that way they could shoot more than their limit of bucks.

Other things were guys using their kids tags or wife’s tags. This was very common. One customer routinely shot 25-30 deer per season. The limit was 6. But he had 4 kids who all had tags (none of them hunted).

Baiting turkeys and ducks was big.

Shooting deer with rifles during bow season. One guy at the store was a taxidermist. He told me a large majority of the big “bow” killed bucks her took in had .22 cal holes behind their ear.
 
Our Provost Marshall and I investigated a large number of poached trophy buck deer on an Army installation I patrolled.
We finally captured one of the group and he rolled over on the others of the party, fortunately.
Those fellas were an interstate poaching group working for a taxidermist.
The poachers were cutting the heads off the deer and leaving the rest.
They were equipped with night scopes, centerfire rifles, and good communications.
The court gave them prison time, including the taxidermist. They also faced federal weapon charges upon release.
When we were holding the one we caught, he was sitting in our interview room at HQ. He retained his cocky attitude and thought he was going to receive a citation and leave. I had the pleasure of informing him he was being transported to jail and that wiped the cocky smile off his face.
 
There's a lot of people who really want to be in a picture with a trophy and will do whatever it takes to do so.

I can't imagine being around that many people who profess to commit crimes openly in public.....but look on the bright side, if you ever need help killing someone, you know which of your acquaintances not to trust...lol.

I had a classmate shoot a bear on Kodiak and in Washington in the same year, both on resident tags. Akfg showed up in Washington and confiscated the animals and prosecuted him for a lacey. I don't know if he ran his mouth or they just randomly found it....but they didn't mess around. That was 25 plus years ago before AI was even a thing. I make 100% sure to tell everyone who relocates that story because it cost that guy a pile and his dad was an attorney.
 
When I hunted the Utah this year during the "spike hunt" there were ATV's coming down past my camp all night long 1:00AM-2:00AM almost every single night. Lot of shooting going on around us but everyone we talked to said they didn't see anything.....One night I shined my light out to see whop they hell it was and there was a guy on a 4 wheeler with a big rack on it going by my tent as fast as he could go. Just the rack. It was a poachers paradise there with that "Spike hunt" going on. I would wager that a LOT of mature bulls were hitting the dirt on those spike tags. Again, no solid proof but I don't believe in coincidences...

Also, I always wondered how many of those people spending 10 + points on a cow muzzleloader tag are actually hunting cows. I'm not buying that people are that damn stupid or desperate for cow elk meat to spend 10 + years of your life applying to get a cow tag......

1772454360619.png

Or even funnier......

1772454405117.png

1772454471834.png

1772454974264.png

I believe if I was the game warden, this is where I would start sleuthing.

With tags getting harder and harder to draw, poaching is alive and well across the west. I would actually go as far to say that I think it is worse now than it was 20 years ago.
 
Far too often, casually striking up a hunting conversation with aquaintences, strangers, guys at the range, or friends of friends will lead to some sort of poaching admission. In just the last year, I've had this happen all too often. Below are just a few examples off the top of my head:

-Guy at a holiday party showing off pictures of some elk and mule deer he took that season. He shows me a great buck he killed, tells the story of scouting it but struggling to find it after season opened. With a smile he says, "Well, I do cheat a little..." He then tells me how he uses a thermal monocular to spot large heat signatures to "find the big ones" and was able to relocate and kill the buck.

-A corporate guy at work who told me he hunts several different trophy mule deer units across the state by having his ex-wife, girlfriend, both children, and brother all apply (none of whom hunt). When any of these people draw a tag, he hunts and uses their tag and pre-signed proxy statement.

-A friend of the above corporate guy who freely admits to baiting bear illegally... Close to roads, wrong time of year, using prohibited substances, and has at least one unpermitted bait location. A few years ago this guy also made FB posts about him and another guy each killing cow elk in a certain unit, but offline admitted he shot both cows himself in a completely different unit, hundreds of miles away (a different coworker actually reported this and the bear baits to IDFG, nothing has come of it thus far).

-A guy I hunted with a few years back told me he usually kills cow elk during muzzleloader season with a rifle because "it's easier, and you can just say you're wolf hunting if anyone asks." Needless to say I do not hunt with this guy anymore. He also once filled his one and only deer tag, then shot another buck later that season and attached a bear tag to it. He actually got checked at a checkstation on the way home, portrayed it like some big mistake and made it out of there with some sort of a verbal warning and his (second, illegal) buck.

-Brother of the above guy told me he killed a 180" MD buck in a draw-only trophy unit, with an OTC tag for a neighboring unit. He said it was fine because he was "still pretty close to the unit the tag was for."

-this past season, after getting skunked on the draw, I hunted on a general OTC bull tag in a very busy unit with lots of roads (most of which close specifically for this elk season). There were side-by-sides EVERYWHERE, going completely off-trail and tearing up closed roads. More than once my hunting partner and I had hunts blown by people taking 4-wheelers and SxS past us on a closed road. We ran into a guy hunting with his kids, who said he likes bringing the kids because he's "pretty sure that youth can shoot either sex." Spoiler alert, that's not true.

-lots of party-hunting/herd shooting/"oops we shot too many" stories, not to mention the rodeos and making unethical shots at distances outside of hunter capabilities... all stories told with a laugh and excitement to do it again next year.


Is this new? Has it always been this way? I'm ignorant to the "good old days." I am a long time shooter but admittedly a late-ish onset hunter. What I lack in experience I make up for in passion for the wildlife, a love for the outdoors and the hunting experience, care for conservation, and a thirst for knowledge and skills (I always try to contribute to this forum and ask questions humbly and honestly). I hunt the West, and sometimes am lucky enough to take 1, or God willing, maybe 2 game animals a year. I'm not a rich guy. Hunting is not cheap for me. I make financial and social sacrifices to make it happen. To hear guys bragging about taking more than they should just floors me.


TL;DR

Is poaching gradually becoming more prevalent? Has it always been prevalent? Do people just feel more emboldened to share their poaching than they used to?

Thanks for the space to vent.
Me thinks you need a better class of friends🤪🤪
 
Yes it's prevalent. I was hiking in the Gunnison NF a few Septembers back. I hiked into a group of bull moose. After taking some pics and enjoying watching them for a bit, I poked around in the area. I found a mineral block in a small spruce stand nearby.
 
I have it on good authority, that a guy (who is now dead) in a friends deer club here in GA used to shoot every buck he saw during deer season. It wasn't uncommon for him to shoot 6-12 bucks a year. The limit back then was 1......His excuse was "They are all tagged..." He was real sneaky about it too and he simply used all of his families tags to tag them. He didn't see a single thing wrong with doing that. He was the president of that deer club too so nobody said much to him.

Poaching in GA is still pretty bad but it isn't as bad as it used to be because a lot of that "old guard deer clubbers" are aging out and dying off. They were a bunch of savages.
 
In Washington if you turn in a poacher you get 10 added points for your draws. I am sure there is still a fair amount of poaching going on, but it is kept pretty quite. I need to find me some poachers to up my point count. Since I am not a youtuber (they always seem to get a tag with 1 or 2 points) or have millions of dollars to buy the governor's tag
 
Back
Top