So far I am loving my insanity. After I got back from Colorado this year I put the Matthews in the closet and really started to get the insanity dialed in. The thing is definatly a shooter. Suprised me with only being a 6" BH how it shoots. Right now I am shooting it at 84 lbs at 29" Draw with a 502 grain finished weight FMJ at 303 fps. Putting just over 102lbs of KE. Got it sighted in out to 80 will be sighting in the 90-150 this week or this weekend
I'd recommend like already stated try both and see what one feels the best. It's hard to pick a bow for someone because everyone's different. Good luck and let us know what you choose!