My first time in Yogi country was last year because I am lucky enough to live in the end of the state that doesn't have them (yet) I carried a bottle of UDAP and my 45. Looked at the 44 super redhawk but I will be honest with you, after shooting it I knew that I would not be able to get two good rounds off at a bear let along 6. And the chances of one of those stopping the bear is just about zero unless you hit the spine. After that hunt I was introduced to a guy who has been guiding for a quite a while. He has had only a few bear encounters but all ended peacefully. He told me that he only carries a 45 and so do the other guys he works with. The gun is going to do little more than make a bunch of noise and hopefully scare the bear off. If you do have to shoot, well that is the worse case scenario and will still most likely end bad for you. He doesn't carry bear spray and I am reluctant too but I still will. The reason is, the wind. If there is one thing constant in Wyoming in the mountains it is the wind. The chances of a nice breeze in your face when it occurs or a strong side to side that will pretty much make the spray useless is high. The best advice (I think) that he gave me was. Put your head on a swivel, pay attention of where you are at and what is going on around you. We all do that already when we are hunting. There was also a show on the outdoors channel or pursuit where they took 5 guys who had skills well above mine shooting one of the hip cannons. They showed them shooting at 45 yards and at 20 yards group very tight. Then setup a mobile range where they had series of balls from a kickball size to a beach ball and they rolled it down from the hill. The ground was bumpy and made the ball bounce erratically They set it up so that the ball would be going on average the same speed as a charging grizzly. They told them that they could start shooting at 30 yards to 5. It was their choice when to start. The 5 limitation was for personal safety at that time.. granted you would be firing all you could up to zero hour so I get that. I don't remember the exact numbers but they all "died". I think only two shots out of that group of guys made it into the "bear". When they got to the beachball size ball, they did much better. That still would only wound a bear that was already pissed. So this is how/why I made my opinion. I have no illusions of grandeur about being able to take a 44 and hit a moving target multiple times. I know that I am an average shot with my 45 at stationary targets. But I do know that I stand a better chance of sending more lead down range with it than a 44. So in this case, the best defense is a good offense. Pay attention and learn to understand a bluff charge from the real deal. Granted, you will probably only get to be wrong once. But by overreacting you stand to turn a non-event into a fight for your life. And remember, we are talking about stopping a bear in the tracks... not killing it. Will a 45... no... Will a 44.. no. Very few rifles will. Granted, it just takes a lucky shot in some cases, but if you are unlucky enough to meet a grizz face to face, what makes you think you will be lucky enough for that shot. Or calm enough.
---- It’s a Crumy Life but someone has to do it.
.