Zac, you are much more knowledgeable than I am with tuning, but you do sound like I did with my Prime CT3.
I got so frustrated I ended up setting everything back to factory spec, shims and centershot.
I used my fletched arrows to now re-zero my pins out to 40. Then I went right to broadhead tuning and I shimmed from those results. I think essentially it was so sensitive to front shoulder position, rear elbow, face pressure and especially grip pressure that I couldn’t get consistent results because I couldn’t be ‘perfect’ all the time through paper.
I could pick my other bows and shoot bareshaft bullet holes and shoot them out to 40 so I know my form was consistent enough that my other bows couldn’t pick up on my shooting imperfections.
Broadhead tuning was a breeze though and I found that the bow wasn’t as finicky as bareshaft and paper made me think. I only have used my prime out to 50 yards with broadheads but it drills them no problem.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk