Agree, but when the pack is larger than I need, packing discipline sometimes seems to be an issue and I end up not being smart about what I take. I'm coming to the conclusion that I need a lot less than what I think I do, and as a result my pack sizes have slowly decreased over the years.I definitely fall on the side of preferring to have a larger pack cinched down than a smaller one completely stuffed, albeit with some moderation. I certainly don’t want to take an 80L pack on a day trip but, as mentioned earlier, it can be extremely annoying to have your pack packed so meticulously you can’t repack it easily once you’ve used something from it. Additionally it’s not uncommon that I pick up a shed or something while hunting and it’s nice to have a place to put that.
I would agree most people, myself included, need a lot less than they typically think they do and an easy way to get there is to have a smaller pack. That said, sometimes the “nice-to-haves” are just that; nice to have. Additionally, as you said you usually get a smaller pack with less stuff. Therefore how full your pack is would be roughly the same through the range of gear and pack size, which is similar to where I am at. I prefer to have my pack about 80% full at the start, leaving me with room to add stuff I find while hunting, maybe carry something my buddy brought, repack easily, etc. That’s operating under the assumption though that I pick out my gear and then pick a pack to match. The OP on the hand is in the opposite situation, having the pack first and trying to pick the gear second, to which I would say if it fits it ships. You might run into some issues and inconveniences but I don’t know if that’s enough to justify a new pack for one or two hunts potentially.Agree, but when the pack is larger than I need, packing discipline sometimes seems to be an issue and I end up not being smart about what I take. I'm coming to the conclusion that I need a lot less than what I think I do, and as a result my pack sizes have slowly decreased over the years.
Sea to summit wilderness wipes.HAHA im not as hardcore as a lot of people on here apparently. I may put a smaller roll in there but half a roll of TP's space does not seem life changing