There is already one on Rokslide 300Bee. http://www.rokslide.com/forums/showthread.php?694-Good-guy-list Guess maybe some of you guys havent found it? Hope that helps. I have many honorable mentions =)
I've done several transactions on here too with no issues. I have done some on other hunting forums where the merchandise wasn't exactly in the condition as advertised. Whats in "great" condition no one might not be the same to another I guess.
The "good guy" list on here I find pretty worthless... I'm supposed to dig through 70+ pages of posts to see if someone is a "good guy" or not? It would be much better if there was just a list of good guys. Archery Talk has an awesome way to rate buyers and sellers with comments kind of like ebay. It doesn't have to be that elaborate but the current method kinda stinks. So much that I never even bother looking at it.