the key takeaway is don’t act like an idiot and it will service most people just fine
I agree. I own one. You don't need full power shifts, no automatic transmission can endure that for very long without being rediculously overbuilt. The main problem with it is that it's underbuilt, and the programming to offset that is retarded in the name of driver comfort. It does all that goofy stuff to maintain shift speed and driver comfort. If it would cut fuel, shift, then reapply fuel it could allow higher torque through the driveline, but that would make engine noise every shift and feel like a shift happened. With todays driver comfort standards, we absolutely can't have that kind of stuff.
As I recall the 19-21 model trucks had a double or maybe even a triple whammy;
CGI engine block
CP4 fuel pump
Hydraulic lifters.
Yes, the 19-21 were especially horrible prior to the fuel pump recalls. They went back to CP3 pumps for all of those. The CGI block wasn't really a problem as far as I'm aware. The lifters were problematic at first across the board and now should only be an issue if abused (wrong oil, cold start full throttle, stuff like that).
Seems like they went back to the CP3 for 22-24 models and back to iron block in 2025? Are they still using the hydraulic lifters?
19-24 should all have CP3's now. For anybody reading if you have a 19-21 Cummins and haven't had the fuel pump recall done yet, do it.
The '25 engine has a cast iron block again, I'm not sure if the architecture matches the old one or not. Still hydraulic lifters, a revamped CP4 pump, and glow plugs. Probably quite a few other minor changes I'm not aware of. I believe the ECM is probably 2027 cybersecurity compliant which means it's probably extremely difficult to delete. The CP4 is likely the same revision that Ford is using now, which is dramatically better than old ones. It still aint a CP3 in terms of reliability though. The reality is these things aren't built for durability or reliability at the forefront anymore. They're built to be cheap, quiet, and not shakey. An industrial Cummins engine is none of those things. Solid lifters and CP3 pumps are just too noisy to be acceptable when Ford and Chevy are both making more power and less noise.
Stelantis screwed up big time when they decided they would try to compete with Ford and Chevy rather than stick to what they were good at - being cheaper.