Gaiter Sizing

[Bulldawg]

I'm wondering what you guys think is more important in the sizing of gaiters? When you look at the sizing guides, I either fit into the calf width or the shoe size, and I'm at the bottom of the bottom of the Large calf width but at the top of the XL shoe size. My initial thought is just get the large because I want them to stay up on my calves but I can't remember if that'll cause some issues with them fitting well over my boots.

 

[Habitat#1]

I just bought some XL hoping they would fit over rubber boots and insulated pants but didn't.The Firstlite are good quality though. The size of boot top may make more of a difference