Favorite .357 Revolver?

[NDGuy]

Looking to pick one up in the next few months. I have been looking pretty hard at the S&W 686 and the Ruger GP100/SP101.

What revolvers have you liked? Personal experience with either of these?

Would use it just for fun and carrying in Cat country as I do not have any plans for bear country as of now, although I guess I would be open to looking at a .44 or bigger. I initially was looking at the .357 because I am a smaller frame guy with baby hands, don't want to buy more than I can comfortably and accurately shoot!

 

[danarnold]

357- colt python, I honestly never cary mine in the field anymore, G20 in the field for me

 

[eamyrick]

I have a Ruger GP100 3 inch with Chig grip inserts. When I fly fish Montana I run 180 grain Buffalo Bore. It’s a sweet piece.

 

[wseidel]

I have a S & W 686+ (holds 7 rounds) that is a great carry gun in a Kenai Chest Holster. I recently reloaded some 180 grain hardcast from Performance Bullet Company so I have added penetration for protection purposes. The gun is accurate and has moderate recoil. If you want to consider a 44 magnum revolver, take a look at the S&W Model 69 (holds 5 rounds). I have medium size hands and this fits me well. This is a bit smaller frame than the S&W Model 629 and I use it in Wyoming while elk hunting for bear protection....again in my Kenai Chest Holster. I keep it loaded with the ultimate 44 magnum cartridge for bear protection(in my opinion) - 44 mag Hammerheads made by Garrett Cartridges of Texas (310 grain hardcast). Recoil with this load is stout. That said, many people prefer a 10 mm in a semi-automatic handgun for the ability to carry additional rounds. I personally prefer the simplicity of a revolver. Either way, you give yourself a chance to help yourself (and others) if you find yourself in the horrific situation of a bear/cat attack. Hope this helps. Note: PM me for more specifics.

 

[howl]

SP101 or K-frame .357 with full house loads are painful. GP100 minimum for comfort, L-frames are tolerable. .327 is the max for me in a SP101. This is low end .357 power. Once you get into hot .357 I would rather have a .44. .44 mags are more pleasant for me, even in an L-frame. A large frame, heavy .44mag is much more pleasant to shoot than a light .357.

Hand size needs to match grips, which then match revolvers. So, with a grip frame like a GP100 you can get a grip that matches your hands regardless of size.

 

[DangerRanger]

Having had both i prefer the older security six over the gp100s. I will likely go for smith or a dan wesson to replace my GP

 

[theleo91386]

For a hiking companion I prefer a 3" S&W model 60. It's not fun with full power 357 loads but it's not bad with mid range stuff and 38's. The only way I'd go up to something like a GP100 frame is if I got one in 44 special but that's only because I handload.

 

[Trogon]

I have an old LEO K-frame Model 66 that is smooth as silk and dead accurate. I like the k frame a little more than a j frame for shooting high test, but the j frame model 60 is also a dream to shoot.

 

[jolemons]

Im an sp101 with wood grip kind of guy. Very heavy and well built fun.

Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

 

[rickjames80]

Having had both i prefer the older security six over the gp100s. I will likely go for smith or a dan wesson to replace my GP

I also like and carry the security six. Mine is the 2 and 3/4 barrel. If I were to buy another one, it would have the 4" barrel.

 

[HawkCreek]

357- colt python, I honestly never cary mine in the field anymore, G20 in the field for me

My favorite .357 these days is a 10mm Glock. Once I got my first 10mm it replaced my 686 almost immediately and I never looked back.

 

[Bisley45]

Ive had several 357s and currently don't own any. A 3'' SP101 is a fantastic little revolver, mine was stolen or I would still own it. This is going to sound weird but I really don't like the sharp crack and fast recoil impulse from a 357. I Load a 45 colt to moderate pressures with a 325 grain cast moving 1100 fps, with 800 foot pounds of energy I find it very comfortable to shoot vs 357s.

The GP 101 and 686 are great. Someone mentioned the Smith 69, a five shot revolver, another EXCELENT choice. if I were to buy a packing pistol it would be either a Glock 20, Smith 69, or a SP 101.

 

[Oldffemt]

I’ve owned most of the revolvers you listed. Security Six with 4” barrel is the only one I really miss. I currently have a sp101 also with 4” barrel. It’s nice with mild 357 loads or 38’s but gets to be a handful with stout loads. The factory grips are pretty small so you may like that. I got a set of custom grips for it because I have huge hands. For cat and 2 legged critters, I’d get a 9mm and some stout loads and call it a day. Ymmv

 

[elkduds]

Mine is a Taurus 617 titanium. 7 shots, 2.5 in. barrel, only 25 oz loaded, about half of a G20. I bought it to carry more than to shoot. It is a handful w heavy 357 loads, I practice w 38 special to stay competent, and to limit shooting erosion on the titanium. It is a dream to carry, and I much prefer the medium size frame to a J frame-size snubby. Always goes bang.

 

[gphil]

I pack a gp100 with 6in barrel in bow season and it has been a great pistol, I find the recoil very manageable with 357 loads and minimal recoil with 38 special loads.

My dad has a Smith amd Wesson 629 in 44 mag with a 6.5 in barrel and I personally feel it recoils quite abit more.

Both are great guns, but are also both fairly heavy for everyday carry in the woods, I contemplate getting a lighter pistol but I like the reliability, mild recoil and accuracy of my gp100.

Sent from my VS988 using Tapatalk

 

[thinhorn_AK]

I have an S&W performance center 627 which I carry almost daily, for woods use I like the sp101. If I wa deferring my first 357 and didn’t have any others I’d get a go100.

 

[Ashy Larry]

Anybody have a 327 pc? Local shop has one for a lot less than GB or Buds so it has me intrigued. 23 oz and 8 shot capacity.

 

[Trial153]

I am thinking of grabbing the Kimber K6...anyone have any feedback on it?

 

[NDGuy]

Thanks for all the suggestions everyone! Now I am considering a 10mm glock too after going to my gun range and testing them out lol

 

[NDGuy]

Picked up this gem at my LGS. Went with the 7 shot GP100 with a 2.5in barrel! Felt great in my hands and found it used for $500.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk