Consolidate to one (model) pistol? A few Sigs or a few Staccatos?

[fwafwow]

Several years ago I narrowed down my pistols to mainly Sigs, and especially P320s. Based on recent events and information, I've put my three P320s in condition 3 for the moment, and while their fate remains uncertain, I'm revisiting my prior effort to narrow the pistols I own to possibly going with "one gun" (not necessarily a single pistol, but maybe one model and a few of those).

I think I've narrowed it down to two choices: (1) all hammer-fired Sigs; or (2) a couple of 2011's (most likely Staccato).

1. Sigs -
   • I already own a P226 (MK25) and two P229s (Legion and M11-A1).
   • It seems to me that the manual of arms of these are close enough for a "one gun" approach. (And if not exactly the same, narrowing down to P229 and P226 gets me much closer to the "one gun" concept than the various pistols I have now.)
   • This would mean much less additional expense (if any - 3 is probably enough), especially given the magazines I have for the above (and a Milt Sparks holster for EDC with the M11-A1).
2. Staccatos
   • My first defensive pistol was a Colt M1991A1 Compact, which I still own.
   • My affinity for the 1911 has never gone away, and I've been drawn to the 2011 platform a few times over the years.
   • The Oracle Arms 2311 was recommended to me by a friend of the owner (or one of the owners) of that company. I will dig a bit further to compare
   • Going this route would probably make the most sense (something I don't always do) if I get rid of all of the above pistols, and accessories. But there is a material PITA factor of unloading any gear, and considerable expense in getting new (or even used) 2011's

Options 1 and 2 are not completely mutually exclusive, as I can go with #1, unload some of my P320 gear, and then switch to #2 later. Baby steps.

Any feedback would be most appreciated.

 

[Formidilosus]

Several years ago I narrowed down my pistols to mainly Sigs, and especially P320s. Based on recent events and information, I've put my three P320s in condition 3 for the moment, and while their fate remains uncertain, I'm revisiting my prior effort to narrow the pistols I own to possibly going with "one gun" (not necessarily a single pistol, but maybe one model and a few of those).

I think I've narrowed it down to two choices: (1) all hammer-fired Sigs; or (2) a couple of 2011's (most likely Staccato).

1. Sigs -
   • I already own a P226 (MK25) and two P229s (Legion and M11-A1).
   • It seems to me that the manual of arms of these are close enough for a "one gun" approach. (And if not exactly the same, narrowing down to P229 and P226 gets me much closer to the "one gun" concept than the various pistols I have now.)
   • This would mean much less additional expense (if any - 3 is probably enough), especially given the magazines I have for the above (and a Milt Sparks holster for EDC with the M11-A1).
2. Staccatos
   • My first defensive pistol was a M1991A1 Compact, which I still own.
   • My affinity for the 1911 has never gone away, and I've been drawn to the 2011 platform a few times over the years.
   • The Oracle Arms 2311 was recommended to me by a friend of the owner (or one of the owners) of that company. I will dig a bit further to compare
   • Going this route would probably make the most sense (something I don't always do) if I get rid of all of the above pistols, and accessories. But there is a material PITA factor of unloading any gear, and considerable expense in getting new (or even used) 2011's

Options 1 and 2 are not completely mutually exclusive, as I can go with #1, unload some of my P320 gear, and then switch to #2 later. Baby steps.

Any feedback would be most appreciated.

I used 226’s and 228’s extensively. The P22x series is such a down grade in shootability, that I would just use Glocks…. And there isn’t any reason to do that.


Option 3 is the answer.

1). Get a Stacatto C or CS for main concealed carry.

2). Get a Tisas 9mm 1911 or 2011 for practice and back up uses.

3). Add higher end 1911 or 2011’s when able.


Doing the above, you aren’t “making do” with good enough or wondering what would be better. You have the highest performing pistol platform made.

 

[fwafwow]

I used 226’s and 228’s extensively. The P22x series is such a down grade in shootability, that I would just use Glocks…. And there isn’t any reason to do that.


Option 3 is the answer.

1). Get a Stacatto C or CS for main concealed carry.

2). Get a Tisas 9mm 1911 or 2011 for practice and back up uses.

3). Add higher end 1911 or 2011’s when able.


Doing the above, you aren’t “making do” with good enough or wondering what would be better. You have the highest performing pistol platform made.

I should have known it would not be as simple (or inexpensive) as I envisioned it. And for the C/CS, I had just started to compare the various Staccato models.

 

[Deadspace]

If Staccato can be the answer, it is the answer. Nicest pistols I’ve ever shot.

 

[justinspicher]

I did this a few months ago, but went from a few Glocks to a single Canik.

 

[Dobermann]

@fwafwow - if you're considering Form's suggestion above about the C or CS, here are some videos by Hilton Yam you might find interesting:

And if you really want to go down the Staccato rabbit hole, he has a 42-video Staccato 2011 playlist, including, for example, two or three videos on holster options alone:

Enjoy!

 

[fwafwow]

@fwafwow - if you're considering Form's suggestion above about the C or CS, here are some videos by Hilton Yam you might find interesting:

And if you really want to go down the Staccato rabbit hole, he has a 42-video Staccato 2011 playlist, including, for example, two or three videos on holster options alone:

Enjoy!

Thanks, I think. At the moment I'm suffering (or benefiting) from inertia. Maybe I'm for once rationalizing or being realistic, but I'm probably more than fine with just keeping my 320s in limbo (or for range use or secreted around the house for "grab guns") and tilting my carry to some of my 22x Sigs.

Famous last words...

 

[Diamondback]

I used to own, carry Kimber's, but moved away toward simple Glock 19 / 43 +2 beaters to relentlessly shoot, beat, minor mod without any remorse. Ammo and keeping it simple was the reason.

I would move the Sigs out of your inventory and just keep your M1991A1 Compact.

HK also makes some nice pistols.

 

[fwafwow]

I used to own, carry Kimber's, but moved away toward simple Glock 19 / 43 +2 beaters to relentlessly shoot, beat, minor mod without any remorse. Ammo and keeping it simple was the reason.

I would move the Sigs out of your inventory and just keep your Staccato M1991A1 Compact.

HK also makes some nice pistols.

Sorry, I edited my original post to make clear the M1991A1 is a Colt. I don't own a Staccato.

 

[joshs]

Thanks, I think. At the moment I'm suffering (or benefiting) from inertia. Maybe I'm for once rationalizing or being realistic, but I'm probably more than fine with just keeping my 320s in limbo (or for range use or secreted around the house for "grab guns") and tilting my carry to some of my 22x Sigs.

Famous last words...

I'm a big fan of TDA pistols and the "pick one and practice" mindset, so I wouldn't be concerned about going this route. Especially since it sounds like you are already pretty set on pistols and support gear. 22x Sigs are also a durable, reliable, and proven platform that are generally more shootable than many give them credit for.

2011s take a more dedicated user than modern service pistols. If you go to a USPSA match, you'll regularly see 2011 shooters cleaning mags every time they hit the dirt. It's certainly possible to have a reliable and durable 2011, but it's just a more sensitive platform than most modern service pistols (especially when it comes to lack of lubrication).

3x 2011 $ also = a lot of 9mm practice ammo for your Sigs

 

[schmidty3]

I'm the gay hipster millennial that has an affinity for CZs.

I don't think the $1000+ staccato premium gives you $1000 more of performance over a shadow 2 carry or compact.

Worth a look.

 

[Q_Sertorius]

I’ve yet to find a pistol that I shoot better or more naturally than my P226 in .357 Sig. Shortly after I bought it, I got a second barrel in .40 S&W so I could shoot cheaper practice ammo. I have put thousands of rounds through it. When I am in good training, I can headshot squirrels with it out to about 25 yards. Although I have several other full-size pistols, I could happily sell them all tomorrow.

I’ve never tried a Staccato, so I cannot compare. My brother loves his CZ pistols.


____________________
“Keep on keepin’ on…”

 

[swavescatter]

I have very little handgun experience but thought this video was interesting.