Coffee makers and grinders

Joined
Apr 14, 2022
Messages
16
This is correct. A quality drip coffee maker has a purpose as being simple and brewing high volumes.

Once you start brewing with niche makers and controlling individual variables, the whole game changes.

I have/had so many different brewers (including >$2k) and grinders (up to the $1k mark). In my opinion, the best daily driver is still a Moccamaster and Ode2.
I have both of those, replaced the Moccamaster with a Fellow Aiden about 6 months ago. The Aiden makes objectively better coffee but I still have the Moccamaster in storage for when something goes wrong with the Aiden. Tons of tech in that brewer. Luckily Fellow has a great warranty policy.
 

Team4LongGun

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 4, 2019
Messages
1,914
Location
NW MT
Dark roast has less caffeine. More heat exposure = decreased caffeine from what I understand.

Never knew that! Well, I don't know much about coffee other than I prefer the bold taste, hence my grinder recommendation.
I still put a touch of sugar and creamer in so it ends up normal.
 
Joined
Apr 14, 2022
Messages
16
Caffeine is relatively heat stable, there might be slightly less caffeine in dark roast but the real reason everyone thinks light roast has more caffeine is the way they measure coffee before brewing. Light roast beans are denser, so if you're using volumetric measuring (scoops etc.) you'll physically get more coffee. If you measure your coffee by weight (which you should do anyway) you'll get about the same strength coffee whether it's light or dark.
 

atmat

WKR
Joined
Jun 10, 2022
Messages
3,457
Location
Colorado
I have both of those, replaced the Moccamaster with a Fellow Aiden about 6 months ago. The Aiden makes objectively better coffee but I still have the Moccamaster in storage for when something goes wrong with the Aiden. Tons of tech in that brewer. Luckily Fellow has a great warranty policy.
I’ve played with the Aiden a bit and like it a lot. I may end up owning one soon.

My concern is longevity/repairability for cost. Sure, you get a 2-3 year warranty, which is great.

Where Moccamaster excels is in repairability and longevity. Last forever, but super cheap/easy parts to replace if it breaks.

Most people dropping >$350 for a drip machine would be disappointed for it to not last 5 years, for example.
 
Joined
Apr 14, 2022
Messages
16
I’ve played with the Aiden a bit and like it a lot. I may end up owning one soon.

My concern is longevity/repairability for cost. Sure, you get a 2-3 year warranty, which is great.

Where Moccamaster excels is in repairability and longevity. Last forever, but super cheap/easy parts to replace if it breaks.

Most people dropping >$350 for a drip machine would be disappointed for it to not last 5 years, for example.
Yeah that's fair. I'm just banking on the fact that the Aiden won't last through it's warranty and will be replaced. Seem to be quite a few issues reported already. As with anything Fellow, I'm sure Gen 2 will be much more robust. The coffee you get with the Aiden, especially smaller volume brews, is unreal. I love being able to change temperatures, bloom time, draw down time and pulse numbers to match the coffee I'm brewing. An 85C dark roast brew makes a tasty cup and I usually hate dark roast.
 

renagde

WKR
Joined
Jul 28, 2018
Messages
1,804
Location
Somewhere in Paradise
For those brewing with a Moccamaster, use a super coarse grind. Think cornmeal or courser. Also I always let it bloom, close off the water flow to carafe until the filter is completely filled with water. Then open up the water flow the whole way. You can even gently agitate the beans while the water flow is off. Get's it very close to a pour over quality pot of coffee.
 
Joined
Feb 26, 2024
Messages
55
Location
KY
Considering I drink coffee by the pot I don’t think a French press would serve me well. I do like coffee out of a French press though.
Bodum makes a 1.5 liter french press, is that not enough? I pull out the 1.5l model whenever we have guests staying at our house.

Baratza burr grinder and Bodum 3-cup french press is the daily driver.
 

atmat

WKR
Joined
Jun 10, 2022
Messages
3,457
Location
Colorado
I could careless about the caffeine, I just want to taste the full flavor of coffee and to get that you need a dark roast.

Light roast equals dirty water.
Most people report tasting more flavors from light roasts than dark roasts. There’s more nuance and complexity to them, in general.

Dark roasts tend to be “overwhelming” to people’s tastes buds.

Do you drink with cream and sugar?
 
Joined
Feb 14, 2025
Messages
12
Buratza burr grinder and a French press but I find myself using the wife's Nespresso more and more, makes a very good cup very fast. At work we have the restaurant style Bunns in 2 and 3 burner...they put the caffeine in the cup but that's about it, if the grind is too coarse it's tea and if it's too fine it'll spill over.
 

Bluumoon

WKR
Shoot2HuntU
Joined
May 4, 2020
Messages
1,413
I could careless about the caffeine, I just want to taste the full flavor of coffee and to get that you need a dark roast.

Light roast equals dirty water.


I’m absolutely spoiled w the coffee I get, they roast on Wednesday and ship on Thurs. Lack of flavor/nuance isn’t an issue. Single origin (mostly African) light roast is where I’ve landed. Problem is if the discount ever goes away that sh*t is expensive. I think I’m at around $105 for 5lbs shipped, used to be $80.
 

LostArra

WKR
Joined
May 9, 2013
Messages
3,782
Location
Oklahoma
I’m absolutely spoiled w the coffee I get, they roast on Wednesday and ship on Thurs. Lack of flavor/nuance isn’t an issue. Single origin (mostly African) light roast is where I’ve landed. Problem is if the discount ever goes away that sh*t is expensive. I think I’m at around $105 for 5lbs shipped, used to be $80.
Give home roasting a try.
It's simple, saves money and coffee is guaranteed fresh.
It takes me about 40 minutes to roast coffee for 10 days in a West Bend Poppery II.
 

Davyalabama

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Feb 23, 2023
Messages
290
I'm just not a grind kind of fellow. I'll stick with folgers from Costco, plus the Kirkland brand bold, mix together. Run it through an old Bunn that was in a house we bought, the Bunn is just the 10 cup glass carafe.
 

Jskaanland

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Mar 19, 2016
Messages
3,010
Location
Washington
Tough ask for any drip coffee maker. You probably won't get it equal to the aero press or chemex.
I know but I had expected a lot more out of the Moccamaster. We have some good friends we stayed with that had a similar unit. I felt like theirs produced better coffee.

I’m absolutely spoiled w the coffee I get, they roast on Wednesday and ship on Thurs. Lack of flavor/nuance isn’t an issue. Single origin (mostly African) light roast is where I’ve landed. Problem is if the discount ever goes away that sh*t is expensive. I think I’m at around $105 for 5lbs shipped, used to be $80.

We buy from a place called GoBena and we love it. We had friends that had an adoption fundraiser (lifesong) setup through them, so a portion of the cost went to help them.

 
OP
DapperDan

DapperDan

WKR
Joined
Oct 25, 2012
Messages
1,461
Starbucks is a place where people who don't like coffee can get their liquid candy bar...

Aside- "if you can learn to enjoy black coffee you'll never be disappointed in life."

Starbucks coffee is disgusting…. But not as disgusting as their political values.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
OP
DapperDan

DapperDan

WKR
Joined
Oct 25, 2012
Messages
1,461
I’m absolutely spoiled w the coffee I get, they roast on Wednesday and ship on Thurs. Lack of flavor/nuance isn’t an issue. Single origin (mostly African) light roast is where I’ve landed. Problem is if the discount ever goes away that sh*t is expensive. I think I’m at around $105 for 5lbs shipped, used to be $80.

And I thought I was spending money at $70 per 5 pounds. I order from blackout coffee company based in Florida. Their signature blends are ok but their partner roasts are really nice.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Sam Colt

Lil-Rokslider
Joined
Jun 27, 2020
Messages
264
Just bought a new Gaggia Accademia to replace the 10 year old one. The retired unit has made over 10,000 coffee drinks over its lifetime. We’re enjoying the touch screen and programmable functions a lot.

I have a Baratza Vario+ and Gaggia Classic at the hunting cabin for when we’re “roughing it” and want to go hands on.

The best purchase ever in my coffee adventure is a Hottop KN-8828B roaster. We buy green beans in bulk and then I develop a roast profile for each type. Nothing lets you dial in the flavor profile of a single origin bean like a programmable roaster. I can make an Ethiopian Harrar burst with blueberry, or a Kauai Acaia pop with mocha and citrus. It’s almost a sin to add milk to some of these roasts.

People with OCD should stay away from coffee! 🤣
 

LostArra

WKR
Joined
May 9, 2013
Messages
3,782
Location
Oklahoma
The best purchase ever in my coffee adventure is a Hottop KN-8828B roaster. We buy green beans in bulk and then I develop a roast profile for each type. Nothing lets you dial in the flavor profile of a single origin bean like a programmable roaster. I can make an Ethiopian Harrar burst with blueberry, or a Kauai Acaia pop with mocha and citrus. It’s almost a sin to add milk to some of these roasts.

People with OCD should stay away from coffee! 🤣
I'm holding out for an Aillio Bullet at a yard sale.
 

tdhanses

WKR
Joined
Sep 26, 2018
Messages
6,036
Most people report tasting more flavors from light roasts than dark roasts. There’s more nuance and complexity to them, in general.

Dark roasts tend to be “overwhelming” to people’s tastes buds.

Do you drink with cream and sugar?
Nope, black and strong is they way I like it.
 
Top